MovieChat Forums > Jane Eyre (1944) Discussion > This movie was more like a good, gothic,...

This movie was more like a good, gothic, horror film


When you watch the 1943 JANE EYRE as a youngster, like I did, you have no idea this was Emily Bronte's classic drama novel. Instead you thought you were watching a good, old-fashioned, black-and-white, haunted house horror film. The black-and-white film set the overtones. The scene was set in a dark, gloomy, old English countryside mansion, too large with too few people in it; too dark at night. Then the scary, insane person wandering the dark hallways in the dark of night put the horror tag on the movie. I don't think the director had that in mind when filming the movie. But he was inadvertently decades ahead of his time in employing light, shadow, dark, gothic-mood-setting, and really not showing the the spook/creature in its entirety. You never saw the insane wife fully for long, which was an excellent technique later rediscovered in quality horror gothic films decades later.

reply

You're right, of course. This film is wonderfully atmospheric and, rightly, a masterpiece. Trouble is, although Charlotte Bronte's novel contains Gothic themes and there is the horror element, it is so much more and it does it a disservice to over-emphasise the darkness. One example, we know that Jane loves Thornfield. Would she feel the same about some spooky, gloomy mansion which would scare a person witless?




Wenn ist das Nunstück git und Slotermeyer? Ja! Beiherhund das Oder die Flipperwaldt gersput!

reply

I think that this gothic melodrama comes closest to crossing over into the horror genre. I notice that 'Rebecca' is now being labelled as horror but that I do object to.

reply