MovieChat Forums > Hail the Conquering Hero Discussion > Post-traumatic stress syndrome question

Post-traumatic stress syndrome question


Don't know if this is the best place to ask, but in the latter half of the movie, Truesmith is having a nightmare. One of the Marines comes into his bedroom after and then says something along the line of "Some guys have them all the time."

I've seen tons of war movies it's only movies from the last couple decades that deal with post-traumatic stress. I can't think of any filmed during WW2 that even acknowledges the effects of post-traumatic stress syndrome. The earliest one I can think of is "The Best Years of Our Lives" (1946) in which Dana Andrews' character has recurring nightmares. Is this movie possibly the earliest to mention it?

reply

Good question. I'm sure it has been alluded to in some other early films, but probably only obliquely. During WWI they used the term ''shell shocked''. At some point in WWII the term ''2000 yard stare'' referred to traumatized troops who couldn't fully focus on their immediate surroundings anymore.

reply

There is at least one other film made during WWII that dealt with the subject, I'll Be Seeing You with Joseph Cotton and Ginger Rogers. According to IMDb, was released in January, 1945, six months after Hail the Conquering Hero. If not as memorable as HtCH, it has a longer, more vivid depiction of PTSS.

reply

There is a movie from 1942 called "This Above All" that deals with PTSD on some level as well. It stars Tyrone Power as a disillusioned former soldier dealing with nightmares and stress after his time at Dunkirk, and Joan Fontaine giving a strong performance as the very patriotic WAC who falls in love with him.

reply

Movies may have been slow to pick up on it, but "battle fatigue," "shell shock," "war nerves," and "PTSD" go back a long way.

I think that the first large scale casualties occurred during World War I. That was one of the first wars fought with nitrate based high explosives and enormous numbers of artillery pieces. It also saw the largest armies deployed up to that time. This combination led to millions of men being exposed to hours of continuous heavy bombardment, and months of dreary, repetitive fighting. This was a huge sea change from previous wars that involved weeks of maneuver followed by a short, vicious fight, and then more weeks of maneuver.

The conditions on the battle field coincided with the early development of psychology. The medical community was just beginning to learn about the mind and the brain in which it resides. Suddenly, they had hundreds to thousands of casualties who could not return to the battlefield and even had difficulty returning to civilian life, whether or not they had visible wounds.

By the time of World War II the doctors were beginning to write texts on the damage that war does to the mind of men. Now, in this new world conflict, more than 12 percent, 16 1/2 million American men went to war. Nearly the entire male population (as well as many females) of fighting age, officially 17 to 36 years old, much older if they had experience went into uniform. They now had millions of patients to study.

The Vietnam generation gave us the appropriate quotation, "All gave some, some gave all."

reply

Sturges has a very serious side, and was apt to place issues such as this into his films.

"What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence."

reply