good or bad ghost?


Why does Irena's ghost materializes to mask over the woman who is hoping to kill the little girl Alice. Alice runs to her, to now have the crazy ladies hands on her neck!

reply

Irena herself didn't materialize to lure Amy into a trap. It was simply Amy mistaking Barbara for Irena in the dim light. To be fair, the two of them did look a lot alike. So much so that at first I thought that Simone Simon was playing a dual role.

So no, Irena's innocent on this occasion.

reply

I thought that for the moment, Irena melded with Barbara and managed to tone down her temper.

Life, every now and then, behaves as though it had seen too many bad movies

reply

That's basically the impression I got - that Irena transferred some of her own compassion for Amy to Barbara, so that Barbara no longer saw Amy as a threat but as a frightened and helpless child.

reply

Exactly: Irena served as a mediator, providing friendship to the socially withdrawn Amy and smoothing out Barbara's rough edges. Really, her character's presence here seemed a bit forced, which is inevitable in a sequel when you kill off your lead character in the original, but it works.

reply

Well, being that that's almost certainly Irena's ghost, the story wouldn't work with a LIVE Irena.

reply

They looked nothing alike. the daughter had angular features and Irena had a rounder face.

I don't think the daughter was a ghost or any of that. the mother for some unexplained reason, probably due to the fact. this was just a subplot for Amy's story.
disliked her daughter. elderly parents do this quite often. I know since my own elderly mother can be this way towards me.

reply

Amy called to her "friend" for help, which was Irena and that is when she saw her face instead of Barbara's. It worked out because Amy calling Barbara her friend melted Barbara's anger toward her. I don't think Irena was a ghost, but a figment of Amy's imagination. I believe all the scenes with them were really in Amy's mind.

"Do All Things For God's Glory"-1 Corinthians 10:31
I try doing this with my posts

reply