The Thirteen


I sure would like to see "Trinadsat," the Soviet movie "Sahara" was based on.

There is only one comment on the movie on the imdb, but I think it is worth quoting here:


"The plot of Trinadsat is also the basis of Bogart's 1943 Tank movie, Sahara. Both films are similar to John Ford's 1934 Lost Patrol about a group of British soldiers who defend an oasis from Arab attackers. Even Ford's film was a remake of earlier version of the Lost Patrol that starred Victor McLaglen's younger brother Cyril. BATAAN (1943), starring Robert Taylor, is a similar film. One should note that Philip MacDonald's novel Patrol is listed as the inspiration of many of these films.

"This version is about 11 Soviet soldiers and 2 Soviet civilians who are crossing a desert on horse in Central Asia. Like in Sahara, they encounter hostiles (White Russians) and take refuge in ruin with an almost dry well. Although clearly inferior in number, they decide to make a stand against the hostiles in the same fashion as Bogie in Sahara, water for guns. Like John Ford's Lost Patrol, a patrol comes upon the lone survivor almost dead from thirst. Unlike Ford's, the patrol makes the final attack on the hostiles. Since this is a Soviet propaganda film, the message is that the collective transcends the individual. This is shown as each inalterable Soviet hero replaces the dead one before him."

I guess this message comes through, somewhat, in "Sahara". John Howard Lawson, who wrote the movie, was a big time Commie. The only other movie of his that I've seen, however, "Algiers" doesn't have an obviously leftist angle. "Sahara" is a strange one. It could be seen to have a Internationalist flavor, except where it explicitly does not, in the scenes where the audience is taught that all Germans are intrinsically evil (unlike Italians).

reply

"It could be seen to have a Internationalist flavor, except where it explicitly does not, in the scenes where the audience is taught that all Germans are intrinsically evil (unlike Italians)."

You'd have to forgive the writer for that, the movie came out in 1943. Hard to make it remotely sympathetic to the Germans.








I have a gift for enraging people, but if I ever bore you, it'll be with a knife. - LB

reply

"It could be seen to have a Internationalist flavor, except where it explicitly does not, in the scenes where the audience is taught that all Germans are intrinsically evil (unlike Italians)."

You'd have to forgive the writer for that, the movie came out in 1943. Hard to make it remotely sympathetic to the Germans.

****

And yet, and yet.... see Powell & Pressburger's "The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp", also made during the war (same year as "Sahara" in fact - 1943), for a sympathetic portrayal of a "good" German.

Mike


reply

Blimp wasn't about WWII.

reply