Jarring!


Fred MacMurray shirtless is just plain wrong, and kind of skeevy. Same with Ronald Reagan.

reply

I didn't mind that, and I thought the line that Claudette used when he was shirtless was absolutely brilliant. I made a note of it and will use that line whenever I get into a flame war with a brainless, doofus male. :)

"You are living proof that men can exist without mentality."

reply

Oh, I disagree. I know it's hard to get Fred-as-the-father-on-My-Three-Sons out of one's head, but he was a big handsome goof - especially when he was younger - and he had a very nice body in this film. Note especially the big thick arms . . .

reply

I have always had a question about shirtless classic stars but don't know how to introduce it.

Using modern fitness standards there seems to be few men who should have gone on screen without a shirt, and IMO 'the others' doing it, sometimes ruins the romantic angle at least a bit....

How many Amish does it take to screw in a light bulb????

reply

Maybe you have impossibly high standards in male physique. ;)

reply

But don't you think modern standards are a bit ridiculous? No one really looks like that. They must spend hours a day training, often taking drugs and/or having surgery to complete the look. FM was a rancher, farmer and sportsman with the moderately muscular build of an active man. Give me a normal body any day!

reply

They DO spend hours training to get their bodies ready to look shirtless. And dieting. They don't try to hide that from the public.

reply

I just watched this movie and never recall seeing him as a fit, muscle-man type before. I even wondered if Fred MacMurray did some bulking up before the shoot. He did have very nice arms. I didn't think it was creepy...it even opened my eyes a bit!

reply

I agree.

People need to get over the idea that actors who played father or mother figures in later life were always middle-aged family sitcom or Disney stars, or that they are creepy because you'd hate to see your parents in scenes like that. I was a bit shocked when I first saw Fred in Double Indemnity. :) But I got over it.

reply