MovieChat Forums > Hangmen Also Die! Discussion > Outstanding film (spoilers)

Outstanding film (spoilers)


I was fortunate enough to watch, for the first time, One of Our Aircraft is Missing on the eve of Remembrance Sunday this year. This particular film was a powerful propaganda piece that paid testament to the Netherlands people under Nazi occupation whilst their government was exiled to London. It took the kernel of a true story to create a superb fictional story. I gave that film 10/10.

Everything I've written above applies to Hangmen Also Die except that it's about the Czechoslovakian people. I give the same rating of 10/10 to this masterful propaganda piece with its brilliant plot twist. There is so much one could write about the film but much has been written already in the reviews posted by others for this film. What I would like to write out are the words spoken by Professor Novotny (Walter Brennan - loved him in this) to his daughter Mascha for his son when he believes he is about to be executed:

What I want to say to you my son is meant for you as a grown man. When our mighty invaders have been thrown out of our land for quite some time. I hope you will be living in a free land where the people are truly governed by themselves and for themselves. Those will be great days. To live in the land where all the men, women and children have enough food to eat and time to read and think. Talk things over with one another for their own good. When such days do come don't forget that freedom is not a thing one possesses like a hat or a piece of candy. The real thing is fighting for freedom. And you might remember me. Not because I've been your father but because I also died in this great fight.

Such poignant and inspirational words. It makes me tearful just typing these lines out.

There was mention in the film, quite early on, from one of the underground members to Dr Svoboda about the need for men of courage and fighting spirit after the Germans were driven out of Czechoslovakia. Prophetic words given the country's uneasy relationship with the Russians post-war that ended with latter invading and occupying Czechoslovakia in the late 60's.

One masterful touch I want to mention also was the shot following Gruber's death. All we see are his feet dangling over the side of the table. I thought that was a wonderful way to demean Nazi power by illustrating his diminutive height and showing his vulnerability. The way in which the two doctors move slowly towards him like a hunting pack and then Horak's shadow appears at the doors and we know then that Gruber - the intelligent and wily Nazi - is doomed. Wow!

Did you say my eyes or thighs are beautiful?

reply

I agree that it's a masterful and quite clever suspense movie with multiple excellent setpieces - and, as usual with a Lang picture, it's also outstandingly shot. Where it runs into a bit of a trouble, is the characterizations, with the Nazis being little more than your usual cackling caricatures of evil and the Czechs coming across as somewhat too broadly upstanding and noble. Likewise, I could have done with a little less of the excessively overt, preachy speechmaking, but I guess that's something one has to live with, considering the circumstances (apparently, Bertold Brecht did not see it that way though, wishing to disassociate himself from the film after the fact). In the end, however, it wasn't too difficult to overlook the shortcomings - it's such a thrilling ride.



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

the Nazis being little more than your usual cackling caricatures of evil and the Czechs coming across as somewhat too broadly upstanding and noble
I guess that's the propaganda aspect that doesn't carry well across the generations. I'm glad you enjoyed it notwithstanding the shortcomings.
A bird sings and the mountain's silence deepens.

reply

Now that I've read some reviews of Hangmen, I think I appreciate it even more (which reminds me... we briefly talked about that Un Flic piece... there, too, I found a few reviews/essays that introduced some new, more worthwhile perspectives on that particular "flick". Not that I necessarily like it better now, but it's sure more interesting to think about it in hindsight).

Oh and as an aside... I've sort of kept an eye on your choices in that FG yearly poll and I be damned if there's been a single year where we've had more than 3 films in common in our respective top tens. It's almost beginning to defy laws of probability...



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

I've sort of kept an eye on your choices in that FG yearly poll and I be damned if there's been a single year where we've had more than 3 films in common in our respective top tens. It's almost beginning to defy laws of probability...
Do you mean we have 3 films in common each year, or we have never had any more than 3 films in common? My contributions in my yearly poll varies a great deal; some years I've not seen any film from the particular year for a long time. Other years my turn over of films is greater and my top 10 has changed from previous poll contributions. I see from the 1962 poll that we have two choice sin common, La Jetee and Ivan's Childhood.
A bird sings and the mountain's silence deepens.

reply

I mean we've never had more than 3 films in common... and quite often less than 3. In 1962 it's more like on me though - if I wasn't quite indifferent to the big popular favourites Lawrence Of Arabia & To Kill A Mockingbird (as well as that Liberty Valance film which isn't on your list, either), there would be 4!



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

I had Mutiny on the Bounty on my list but after two new watches (Mamma Roma and Renoir's The Elusive Corporal) it got bumped out of my top 10. I can see why you, or others, might not care for Lawrence of Arabia but I'm surprised you are indifferent to To Kill a Mockingbird. The film has a special place in my heart because we studied the book for school when I was 15 and watched the film as a result. I've seen the film many times since then and still think it conjures up great atmosphere.

The amount of films I've seen each year from the 1950's backwards drops off so we may see more crossovers in our top 10.

A bird sings and the mountain's silence deepens.

reply

Pretty mediocre propaganda movie. Mind you, I've seen much worse in this genre.

Too preachy, too inconsistently paced, too uneven in performances.

reply

I agree that it's good in general. There's a lot of dirty business in it, which can be difficult to watch though. Also some of the sections seem overly drawn out. We know what's going on, we get it, but the film doesn't get on with it.

reply