MovieChat Forums > Dead Men Walk (1943) Discussion > Like watching 1920s German horror films ...

Like watching 1920s German horror films with dialogue.


'Dead Men Walk' was a far better movie than I expected. George Zucco's portrayal of evil was subtle for such an amusingly 'deathless' script. He gave me chills when the dead man confronts his twin brother. The lighting and cinematography were beautifully moody and crawly. This film deserves more attention. It's not quite as good as 'Night of the Demon', but those who enjoyed that film might appreciate 'DMW's lack of special effects in favor of delightful character acting.

reply

I respectfully disagree, finding very little of value in this film.

It was tedious, unimaginative, and wholly derivative. The identical-twin wrinkle, the only novelty, was barely exploited at all (a commoner mistakes the vampire for the doctor and summons a small mob--and yet even this was redundant, as the locals had already been agitating for action against the good doctor), and was thus pointless.

reply

I agree that this was a tough watch. I can get your point about the lighting and the expressionism feel to the film, but there are much better examples. Vampyr comes to mind and is a far superior film. And since you mentioned 1920s German Horror, Nosferatu and The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari also come to mind (even if Caligari isn't technically a vampire film).

reply

I agree, this one of the most under rated and unjustifiably forgotten Vampire horrors of all time.
Zucco gives the performance(s) of his life and the movie as a whole far from being derivative is actually influential.
The Vampire Elwyn is subtly evil and supremely overconfident in the manner of a Vampire "fledgling", not seen before or again until "Interview with the Vampire" and "Night Breed".
The idea of the Van Helsing Character and the Vampire being brothers would not be touched on again until "Van Helsing" the exploitation of contemporary setting was copied blatantly by Dark Shadows (Jonathon Frith even assuming Zuccos accent, dress sense and baring for Barnabas Collins).
Myton's Script is superb and has touches of character developmental and driving elements that would not be used again until Stephen King wrote Salem's Lot forty years later, the wavering ambiguity of the Doctors assistant accidentally instigating the rampaging mob and causing the inevitable tragic climax is a prime example.
The cinematography is beyond reproach, as is the inventive use of lighting to elevate the basic special effects to believably realistic.

The opening monologue spoken by the ghostly Zucco from the flames of the burning tome on Vampirism in the fireplace is particularly effective and almost certainly inspired Sirius Blacks preferred method of communication in the Harry Potter Movies.

Atheism is a religion in the same way that celibacy is a sexual position

reply