Best scenes (spoilers)


I finally got to watch this film and it was far better than I had expected - well written and acted and even harrowing, unlike many films of the period. My favourite scenes are:

When the vicar says something like 'I am a minister of the Christian religion and will not bow down to those opposed to it' then goes to ring the bells and is shot;

When the postmistress kills the German and is almost overcome with the horror of what she has done;

When the Home Guard get shot while cycling home;

When the Vicar's daughter, rather than tell everyone that there is a spy in the house, takes the revolver and merely says 'is this loaded?'

Brilliant acting!!

reply

Yep!

"You're a true vulgarian, aren't you!"

reply

[deleted]

The hand grenade moment is really shocking as it comes from absolutely nowhere.

Its also effective now because it is now such a cliche but then?

reply



The last ten or fifteen minutes when the sailor and his dad innocently hook up again with the quisling (Leslie Banks) had an atmosphere of tension that very few modern films have ever evoked in me. For such a creaky old film, with some really hammy acting, some aspects of it were brilliantly done, like those few scenes - and the denouement, where the vicar's daughter takes things into her own hands, of course.





reply

"When the postmistress kills the German and is almost overcome with the horror of what she has done"

I thought that moment was really powerful and occurs again when the two girls have the rifles and are shooting at the German soldiers out of the upstairs windows of the manor. The girl on the left becomes faint when she hits a soldier for the first time. I really liked the way people rose to defend themselves but never become these hardened soldiers but instead were kind of terrified of what they found themselves capable of. It makes them and the whole story much more humanistic.

reply

[deleted]

Yes the postmistress scene stands out as it's the first killing of one of the Germans, I believe, and was well built up. Great acting from the woman playing Mrs Collins.

I agree that the violence was shocking at times but that adds to its power especially as a propaganda piece. I found the brutal way that Daisy was treated by her German captor difficult to bear.

I give my respect to those who have earned it; to everyone else, I'm civil.

reply

Just watched this on TCM, loved it. To add some other good scenes:

Young George and the hunter in the rainy woods > both of them getting shot > Young George crawling to safety. Yikes!

Charles Sims cutting the wire in the basement of the church that allows that metal plate to fall on top of the Jerry.

reply

Glad you loved it. I was shocked at the amount of violence in a 1942 film and that the good get killed along the way. Powerful film.

A bird sings and the mountain's silence deepens.

reply