MovieChat Forums > The Black Swan (1942) Discussion > WOW... Eyepopping, garish color.

WOW... Eyepopping, garish color.


It looks so fake, I thought it was colorized. But that's three-strip technicolor.

reply

You call that garish? I call it awesome and totally in sync with lots of other '42 - 80's films.

I'm not psycho, just a little loopy.
*~me~*

reply

Yeah, I thought the production quality of Avatar was far superior. For the life of me can't figure out why they couldn't have made the Black Swan as good.

reply

Because your spoil of today technology which they didnt have back then and I think movie back then are way better then today, atleast acting matter back then.

Maureen O'Hara, Ireland Best Actress. Got Maureen O'Hara and Julie Andrews autograph 2008!

reply

I was trying to be sarcastic, but with all the Avatar fan boys & girls roaming IMDb I can understand why that might not have come through.

The OP might as well have been questioning the sound quality in Birth of a Nation as far as I am concerned.

reply

ooo I am sorry I must have miss the sarcastic remark.. I do apologize.. I just get tired of hearing some people diss some the classics movies because of the quality etc

Maureen O'Hara, Ireland Best Actress. Got Maureen O'Hara and Julie Andrews autograph 2008!

reply

I LOVE the eye-popping colour... there's no subtlety, but this isn't the type of movie that needed subtlety. I find many of today's movies almost too dark... there are scenes in the PoTC & HP movies that I have difficulty making out because of the overall darkness.

reply

Guess I'm just not a fan of the cartoonish feel of the coloring. I'll take Captain Blood's B&W any time.

reply

Yeah, I thought the production quality of Avatar was far superior. For the life of me can't figure out why they couldn't have made the Black Swan as good.
by - jstang411 on Mon Mar 8 2010 08:17:37

nice

I liked the colouring but honestly, what were you expecting from a film starring 'The Queen of Technicolour'?

reply

Your eyes are retarded.

There's some mistake. I'm not a member of the Columbian Record Club....

reply

It's not garish, it's wonderful glorious technicolor. I love it.

Jessica Rabbit
"I'm not bad. I'm just drawn that way."

reply

I agree, it's beautiful. One of the first full-blown Technicolor films I fell in love with.
You should have replied to the Original Poster, who's eyes are retarded!

Guys in suits buying used girl panties in vending machines. How is that okay?

reply

I loved the lighting of the cabin aboard the Black Swan. It looked great.

reply

Technicolor loved Maureen O'Hara. I like it. What did you except when watching old movie?

reply

You're used to the drab, drained colors in most of today's movies! They're horrible! Many look as if they were filmed on an overcast day; while some have that yellowish/greenish/greyish cast. Or, the screen is so dark that you can't tell what's happening, even when it's not a night scene. This is an escalating problem in films in the 21st century. I thought it was due to the overuse of CGI. Now, I think it's because the so-called cinematographers need to go back to school!

TCM is such a relief: seeing films in "glorious Technicolor" and even the earlier pastel-looking procress.

I am so happy when I happen across a film in the 2000s that has beautiful, clear color. The LOTR trilogy is a wonderful example. And, I can't fault CGI always because "Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow" is a feast to my eyes. "POTC" started out wonderfully, but the third one was lacking in color and clarity. However, the fourth one returned to what now seems an old-style look.

You can have that horrible look! Sadly, it has killed far too many films for me.

"The Black Swan" is lushly gorgeous! Films should assail our eyes with color! Someday, film historians will look at that washed-out, overly dark style and wonder, "What were they thinking?!"



*** The trouble with reality is there is no background music. ***

reply

Garish? The Oscar winning Technicolor cinematography is one of the film's greatest draws.





My friend, you are soured by too much contact with humanity.

reply

Didn't know it won an Oscar, and perhaps rightfully so, but it does look cartoonish today.

reply

Are you kidding? This film is a beauty! You've worn out your eyes on digital, my poor chum, if you can't appreciate that gorgeous Technicolor anymore (it actually won a well-deserved Oscar for the photo). This is cinematographic art at its finest.

__________________________
www.1up-games.com Last watched: imdb.to/K4tvL9

reply

I think "art" is the key part in your statement. It certainly doesn't hit the eye as realistic.

reply