Why not remake??


Yes there will NEVER be talent such as Lord and Lady Olivier but Lord Nelson and Lady Hamilton's story deserves to be told to a different generation!! Especially Emma's lifelong celebrity from cortesan to mistress exordinaire!

reply

It was remade, in 1973, under the British title "Bequest to the Nation" and the American Title, "The Nelson Affair." It starred Peter Finch as Horatio, Lord Nelson, and Glenda Jackson as Emma, Lady Hamilton. It was well done. I have never seen "That Hamilton Woman" with Olivier and Leigh and would love to see it and own it. Does anyone know where a copy could be purchased?

reply

Less than one year later, TCM comes through with a showing this morning. I only caught the end, but the plot and players are especially interesting.

In response to the question why not a remake? I never understand why we, as a people, can't just enjoy the original, which is usually just another version of an older story. Some movies may benefit from a remake, but I would say those are very few and far between, and I would be hard-pressed to think of a single "black and white" or color movie, at least those I know and love, that would benefit from being remade.

reply


This film is already an remake, isn't it? There was made a film about Nelson and Hamilton in the 20s.


Don't tell me, it's no use to me. Tell yourself if you want to but don't tell me.

reply

call marty scoreses and tell him to get on this right away it would be very popular today...

reply

I thought this was a great film. I understand the angle on remakes if the newer production has some different take on the subject, but just to redo an excellent film for a new audience? WHy can't they see the older film?

Anyway, see this film. It was great.

reply

I'd ask the opposite question to the OP, why re-make this film?

Especially since you say yourself that no actors would make it better than these did.

As for a new generation, I'm in my 20's and I watch lots of "old" movies. I enjoy them and they don't bore me - I guess it has to do with having an attention span and a working imagination. It's exceedingly rare that a "re-make" is better than an original, although if you look around there are tons of movies that you wouldn't have even known were re-makes of other films. It just takes some searching and you realize the same stories are being told a lot of the time anyway.

To me, re-making any truly wonderful movie would be like re-writing a classic book and slapping a new cover on it & new illustrations inside! Surprised they don't do that yet - I'm sure they'll be re-making this one soon enough, though, just for the $, since it takes very little creativity and since very few people have enough imagination and long-term memory in our world culture today to just watch and appreciate the original...

Forgive me, but it pains me to see this question asked repeatedly on the page of every awesome older movie that I look up on imdb...

reply