Favorite Scene


When they're in their bedroom (Carole's boudoir) and they haven't left the room for days because they've fought and she has that rule about not leaving until they've made up and the dirty dishes are piled up all over and Robert Montgomery makes believe he's left the room and Carole looks up, registers disappointment and then Robert pops up from behind the couch, etc.

Call me crazy, but I believe this scene may have influenced Luis Bunuel's "Exterminating Angel", wherein guests at an upper class dinner party find themselves unable to leave the dining room!

reply

I can't speak to Bunuel's Exterminating Angel, but that opening sequence in the bedroom, all without dialogue, is wonderful - you can tell Hitchcock came up in the silent era. He could really tell a story without relying on talking heads.

I love this film so much, it's hard for me to pick a favorite scene, but I'll throw out another which is one of my favorites, the dinner party at the Florida Room. The two "society gals - real class" that Chuck Benson brings along and what with Robert Montgomery's trying to pretend that he's talking intimately in the ear of the woman seated next to him who is actually a stranger and there with her own date (the ubiquitous James Flavin), was hilarious!

reply

A very, very funny movie -- up there with Preston Sturges' best -- but I have to agree, out of all the great scenes in the film my favorite has to be the scene with Montgomery "whispering" into the stranger's ear! I was just showing that scene to my elementary school-aged kids, who had never seen the movie nor were they familiar with any of the actors, and even they had to laugh out loud, especially when the camera pulls back and you see both the girl and her date staring angrily at him...! Comedy gold.

reply

The scene at Mama Lucy's Restaurant cracks me up every time. He says, 'I'd pay $5 to see that cat eat this soup...'

reply

Makes me want to watch it again...thank you for posting. 

"No, I don't like to cook, but I have a chicken in the icebox, and you're eating it."

reply