MovieChat Forums > Young People (1940) Discussion > Children's Liberation in 1940

Children's Liberation in 1940


The song "Young People" expresses juvenile rebellion against adults to an extent that I found surprising in a film from 1940. It shows how 12-year-old Wendy (Shirley Temple) fills all the children's heads with kids-lib ideas, which they then express to their parents in the song that Wendy stages for them. To see how strong the kids-lib message is, just look at a few of its lines and their implied meanings.

When we're in the parlor and the lights are low,
Don't bribe us with a nickel, we'll refuse to go.

Meaning: "Just because you (our parents) want to get cuddly in the living room, don't ask us to leave."

Sisters, better tell your romantic gents --
We have a minimum lover charge of fifty cents.

Meaning: "If you (our older sisters) invite your boyfriends over to make out, you'll have to pay us not to tell." That kind of kiddie-blackmail, played upon older siblings and babysitters, is so common that it's been joked about in the media for decades. (And note that "lover charge" is obviously a sarcastic parody of the term "cover charge.")

We know our table manners, when to use a knife and fork,
And we know that the Stork is a nightclub in New York.

There was indeed such a nightclub; but, just possibly, that line may have meant something like:
"You (our parents) lied to us! You didn't get us from any stork. And now we know how you DID get us." (Guess who told them?)

And probably the part most disturbing to the parents was:

We hate to hear a fairy tale before we go to bed;
We'd rather have you telling us what Walter Winchell said.

Winchell was a famous newsman and commentator who hung out at the Stork Club with New York's celebrities, and was known for having a big mouth about their "gossip" as well as current events and politics.

reply

Fascinating point you've made about this underrated Shirley Temple movie, one of three directed by her best director, Allan Dwan. (Along with the great Heidi and the very fun Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm).

reply

Shirley was 12 but her character Wendy is 11. Ever since Temple got her contract with Fox, they made her a year younger but unfortunately Fox terminated her contract a year early.

It would be so nice if something would make sense for a change.
Alice in Wonderland

reply

The whole film seems to have been carved out of bits and pieces from the previous year's "Babes in Arms", just like "The Blue Bird" was out of "The Wizard of Oz". The big number that is interrupted by the parents pulling their kids off of stage is just like the title song, while Kathleen Howard's character is an expanded version of Margaret Hamilton's. They just give Shirley's parents more to do.

"Great theater makes you smile. Outstanding theater may make you weep."

reply