MovieChat Forums > Rebecca (1940) Discussion > Perfect cast, but TERRIBLE acting!!

Perfect cast, but TERRIBLE acting!!


I guess it was just a thing of the times! But I couldn't keep silent on the matter any longer after re-watching the "going downstairs in Rebecca's costume" scene. I think the only one who pulled anything remotely close to good acting off was the woman who played Maxim's sister. Even she cried out: "Rebecca!" which was ultimately a cheesy moment. But Maxim "looked up" in an awkward way, the second D was laughing but crying: "What have I done!?" and even Mrs. Danvers was her usual melodramatic self. I don't know why people acted so badly back then, when future, much later roles PROVE they can act terrifically. Times have changed, but where was common sense!?

CDEGFEDCC. (Shhh!)

reply

Nonsense. This was a very well acted film from beginning to end.

reply

Oh dear, you really think so? I'm afraid I don't agree at all. It was awful! Embarrassing!

CDEGFEDCC. (Shhh!)

reply

Did Maxim kill Rebecca or she hit her head herself somewhere?

reply

'I guess it was just a thing of the times!' You must be kidding, If you think acting today is better than acting back in 30's, 40's, 50's, ect. You must be idiotic, The best acting performances ever came 'from the times' Go back to your precious Tom Hardy and Leo Dicaprio.

reply

Yes, in the novel Maxim killed Rebecca but she egged him on hoping he would do it. In the movie due to the times it was not acceptable for a hero of a story to do that, so they made it that she slipped and fell and hit her head. Hmmm.

CDEGFEDCC. (Shhh!)

reply

I thought it was a great film with excellent acting.

reply

Sorry OP, but you don't know anything about film acting, no matter how many film classes you've taken or books you've read.

reply

It was so melodramatic and over-the-top. But unintentionally funny at times.

reply