ending?


How does freya's ex fiance know she died? Why wasn't Martin able to save her with his medical skills?

reply

Well, we aren't told/shown how much time has passed since her death and his informing her brothers... there could've been a letter. Maybe he told them without knowing - because uncertainty would be worse, and as a bonus they could blame Martin the non-Nazi. Or maybe he just assumed she died from the amount of blood on the snow, and by knowing the facts that answer your second question:

1. Martin was a vet, not a people doc;
2. they were in the middle of the wilderness;
3. it was the middle of winter;
4. and it's quite doubtful he'd brought many medical supplies - if any.



Last seen:
The Mortal Storm - 9/10

reply



I assumed Martin entered the tiny town with a dead woman in his arms and word quickly spread - even back across the border to the Nazis.

reply

"How does freya's ex fiance know she died?"

He saw the blood in the snow. The rifle bullets in those days were not BBs or '22s, they were very high powered bullets, and they caused horrific wounds. Being hit with one, death was a foregone conclusion, even if you were at the doorsteps of a hospital.

"Why wasn't Martin able to save her with his medical skills?"

See above. Being hit with a high-powered rifle bullet is not a minor inconvenience. These things are designed to kill, and not to cause some minor discomfort.

You've been watching too many action movies.

reply

Actually a .22 can be more deadly and from a longer range than many high powered rifles (not to be a jerk here, I know what you're saying) but, for the record, the .22 bullet has a tendency to enter the body, bounce off a bone (rib etc.,) and shatter into a multi pronged glob of lead that then continues to bounce around damaging multiple internal organs on its way to its final resting place.Doctors have a hard time saving the victim because,although the entry wound is evident,just where the bullet traveled to, and what damage it did as it spun around internally, becomes a guessing game and a race against the clock, without x-ray equiptment etc. immediately available. A .22 can be deadly from up to a mile away ! In fact, in my home town, a woman was hanging clothes in a closet when an errant slug from a hunters .22 rifle, from almost a mile away, came through the window and killed her where she stood! Absolutely true story.High powered rifles slugs at times go clean through the body - of course most of the time a vital organ is destroyed beyond help but they have been known to pass clean through missing vital organs and not killing the victim. Internal bleeding from the .22 slug is what's most troublesome as it is usually from multiple internal wounds from a single slug. If you go by the reaction of the victim in this movie I would guess a high velocity rifle like the .22 ! She was able to speak, did not appear to be in too much pain and it took awhile for her to die. This is what you would expect to happen to a victim of a .22 rifle slug if the victim was being carried some distance with no immediate medical intervention - slowly bleeding to death as the seconds ticked by. Yes, I know, this is a Hollywood ending and yes more than likely the Nazis would have been toting high powered rifles. I just wanted to clear up the ".22 small caliber so not as deadly" mis conception most people have. It can, at times, be VERY deadly and from a long ways away !

reply

[deleted]

Precisely. The German Mauser rifle fired a 7.92 mm round - a big bullet that bounced like crazy in the human body. It killed a lot of American soldiers in two world wars. That's the weapon the Nazis in the film were using.

reply

Absolutely. After all, the 5.56mm fired by the M-16 is a .223 Remington, small but a tumbler, and very deadly. The Russians now use the AK-74, which fires the 5.45mm Soviet, a refined version of the American slug. You are entirely correct about high-powered rounds, but intermediates like the .308 Winchester and 7.62mm Soviet can be merciless as well. They don't tumble, but they do bounce inside the body.

reply

He probably could tell by looking at them with his binoculars. As for why Martin couldn't save Freya - there was no time. Besides, he was a veterinarian and she wasn't a horse.

"Does it hurt here, Freya? Neigh once for yes and twice for no."

reply

LOL !!!

reply

I think that is the magic of the ending, you can wonder if he assumed Freya was dead, she was limp when Martin Skied off with her and the blood in the snow.

Which could leave some viewers to wonder if once they got out of range of the Mauser's he could use his veterinary knowledge to save her or check her wound.

Overall the death of our heroine in this movie helped to cement the idea that stance the brothers had taken was extremely wrong and that Stack's character had came to that realization too late.

reply

I certainly agree with that. Ironically, the late Robert Young always said "They Won't Believe Me" was his only "bad guy" role. I'd hardly call him one of the "good guys" in this film.



"I had to give the order to fire! It was my duty!"

reply

I think that is the magic of the ending, you can wonder if he assumed Freya was dead, she was limp when Martin Skied off with her and the blood in the snow.

Its fair to say Freya died partly from Martin's reaction and to a larger extent the context of the final scene with one of her younger brothers reflecting on his life before the rise of Nazism, indicating his regret.

"I'd rather be hated for who I am, than loved for who I am not".

reply

I am forced to agree. Even a veterinarian caqn tell if a human being is alive or dead.

reply