Begs to be remade


The Letter always struck me as an over-wrought, over-rated soapy women's melodrama to be quite frank. The treatment it is given in this so called 'classic' is awful. The original version with Jeanne Eagels hits closer to the mark for me. But ultimately no filmed version of The Letter has really succeeded. They've all descended into the absurd in their final scenes, that awful 'with all my heart...' bit. In the case of the Bette Davis film, there's only so much of Davis pacing and wringing her hands I can take. Probably one of Davis' worst performances in my opinion, and even William Wyler's direction - beyond that stunning opening sequence - is off kilter.

I reckon this begs to be revisited and I'd personally love to see it done with Helena Bonham Carter in the lead role, with greater and more realistic development of characters and narrative.

reply

A bit drawn out....accused of murdering one lover-falling for her defense lawyer-poor Herbert Marshall

reply

A remake would be a disaster. Hollywood would inevitably ruin it.

reply

I love this movie WITH EVERY FIBER OF MY BODY! (Hold close-up). Saw the 1929 version on TCM today. Pales in comparison with Bette's version, although the '29 version is praised to high heaven on IMDB.

reply

It was remade in 1982 with Lee Remick. The supporting cast included some good actors like Ian McShane, Jack Thompson, etc.

I don't know everything. Neither does anyone else

reply

Is this film lost. Has anyone seen it?

reply

I saw it a long time ago. I just looked on EBay and all they had were two still pictures of her and Ian McShane from it. You might enter it as a want on EBay and they will send you an alert if one is offered for sale. It will probably be a VHS tape. I did see one person selling copies but they sounded as if they were pirated copies.



I don't know everything. Neither does anyone else

reply