MovieChat Forums > The Great McGinty (1940) Discussion > Loved it! But wished for a few things...

Loved it! But wished for a few things...


I thought this little film was a gem! Especially since I've just seen it, mid-Summer in the run-up to a Presidential election. It made the film, and all the nuisances from the campaign trail all the more enjoyable.

So, in the Code-era edict of "crime doesn't pay" wouldn't you have thought that the poor wife, played by the lovely Muriel Angelus, would have somehow come out alright? I mean, aside from just the little nest egg that McGinty left her? And McGinty didn't do so bad, he's certainly no worse off than when he first met the boss. It didn't seem like he had to face the music, really. At least not in the context of this film's time and era.

I thought that the wife's part was a little one-dimensional and that her getting cast aside by the end was handled clumsily.

This is the first film in which I've seen Brian Donlevy so animated and he really came across as a live wire. I loved him in Impact and Hangmen Also Die, but in both of those he was so serious the whole time.

reply

Well that's kinda the point. McGinty and Boss got away with it.

However I was a bit pissed off that his wife didn't join him down there. Well well.

Somebody here has been drinking and I'm sad to say it ain't me - Allan Francis Doyle

reply

They didn't really.Their finishing up in exiled poverty was the least the Hays Office would accept. Although surely there'd have been a lot of graft for the Boss in McGinty's slum clearance plans?

reply

I also think he was well rid of that prissy - wife!

reply