MovieChat Forums > La règle du jeu (1950) Discussion > Frances Finest...best movie from each co...

Frances Finest...best movie from each country?


France: "The Rules of the Game" I have read reviews on this very site giving it 1s and 2s, and giving long winded reasons why. To each his own, all I can say is Enjoy your transformer movies and I'll stick to the great classics.

America: "Citizen Kane" that was a tough choice.

Italy: "Bicycle Thief" Nobody usually argues this. It may be the movie we show alien visitors one day and say "This was our greatest Achievement in moving pictures.

U.K. "The Third Man" it's so good. I thought about "Kind Hearts and Coronets" and Some David Lean movies, but Welles was the tie breaker for me.

Japan: "Ikiru" I fully understand "Tokyo Story" is the consensus, but I love Kurosawa, and this is his great Masterpiece. (Among so many others he made)

Sweden: Which Bergman movie right? I say the unedited version of "Scenes from a Marriage"

Germany: "World on a Wire" thank you for the Blu-Ray Introduction to this Masterpiece, Criterion. This gets the Gold medal in my book. I wouldn't argue many Fritz Lang movies though.

Russia: Soloris (right?)

I have watched 1000's of movies from these country's. While I've seen many from all the country's making movies over the last 100 years, I can't say I've seen enough to say the best from other country's.

My Honorable mention section:
Tokyo Story (Japan)
Barry Lyndon (US)
2001: A Space Odyssey (US)
The nights of cabiria '57 Fellini (Italy)
Casablanca (US)
Rear Window (US)
Note: I'm not ready to say Vertigo is Hitchcock's best, let along greatest movie of all time.


reply

I was going to reply with a list of my own, until I read that stupid comment about Transformers movies. Nobody likes a snob.

reply

France-I agree. Last Year at Marienbad is an extremely close second for me, though.

US-I agree.

Italy-La Dolce Vita (A tough one, not because of Bicycle Thieves, but because of Antonioni's L'Eclisse.).

Japan-Tokyo Story. I'm sorry, Kurosawa fans, but this is perfection.

Sweden-Yay, choose the Bergman film! Persona for me.

Germany-Fassbinder and Lang fans are going to be pissed, but to me the great German film is HJ Syberberg's Hitler: A Film from Germany. 7 and a half hours of unmitigated surrealist genius.

Russia-now let's play choose the Tarkovsky! Mirror, by a mile.

Some films from countries I still haven't watched enough films from, but I think it's a pretty safe bet:

Belgium-Jeanne Dielman.

Hungary-Satantango.

India-the Apu trilogy.

Israel-Waltz with Bashir.

reply

Well, I guess we can pretend the comment about Transformers didn't occur!

I would like to say though, this is a fun thread. Interesting to say the least!

America - So so so many great classics to choose from. I guess I'd have to say Psycho, with Make Way For Tomorrow a really close second.

Italy - Easy. Bicycle Thieves (My favorite film of all time) But well, 8½ is without doubt second.

U.K. - Also a tough choice.. many U.K. films could also be regarded as american. I guess I'd have to say Paths of Glory (it's a British enough film, right?)

Japan - If I had to choose just one I'd say Harakiri! If I am to choose an animated film I'd go with Grave of the Fireflies any day of the week. I actually consider that one of my favorites... Ikiru, Rashomon and High and Low are also in the top.

Sweden - Wild Strawberries. Fanny and Alexander Second!

Germany - Metropolis all the way!

Russia - My favorite documentary of all time: Man with a Movie Camera. Otherwise: Stalker. I actually had to go quite far down my Best Films-list to find a Russian film. Made me realize I need to watch more Russian films and certainly more Tarkovsky!

France - Lots of cool films from France! Vivre Sa Vie is my favorite.

Spain - Cria Cuervos. Certainly a land with great cinema which is criminally under-seen!

Mexico - Pan's Labyrinth or Y Tu Mamá También! Mexico's current film wave is without doubt a turning point in cinema at the moment with directors such as Alfonso Cuarón, Alejandro G. Inarritu and Guillermo del Toro pushing the boundaries!

China - In the Mood For Love

Denmark - Jeanne d'Arc (if we regard it as Danish) otherwise Ordet, The Celebration or Vampyr (discussable if it counts as danish as well though).

Greece - Z

Iran - A Separation

India - Pather Panchali or Charulata



Full list of Best Films:
http://www.imdb.com/list/ls058654419/

Cheers!

reply

Wow, you've got it, man!

No, not a citation from some movie (though I'd have one in mind), but serious insight of what 'movie' means. Totally agree, well, kind of. Was Solyaris (I think that's the one you mean) Russian, or Polish?

I can also go along with World on a Wire, a movie that beats Matrix out of the water. Many years earlier, much fewer silly visual effects, much more depth. Including cinematographic depth, but no spoilers here.

I do think you miss - if one talks about alien visitors - some surrealist movie. What about The Exterminating Angel, for example?

reply