maybe greatest scene ever?


The performance by Jimmy Stewart was great but the filibuster scene was in my opinion the greatest job by an actor in a single scene. You feel for Jefferson Smith especially when he can barely speak or stand

reply

I can only agree that scene is among the most powerful I have ever seen. Stewart did a wonderful job and it's so sad, when the telegraphs are brought in. He's truly a man fighting for his ideas and it's a great scene for a climax to the film, testing how long he can stand on to what he believe in.

reply

[deleted]

yeah, that scene where he is talking(well , whispering to payne) and he throws the fake letters to the ground!!! that was great."someone will listen to me"


you can trouble me for a warm glass of SHUT THE HELL UP!!

reply

One of the best scenes in the history of cinema. It never fails to move me because of its brilliance.

reply

I agree. Although I would make it a tie for best film scene ever. The final scene of Dances with Wolves with the warrior shouting to Costner is just as good.

reply

I can't think of one better.

reply

Dances with Wolves sucks first of all. I would also say that the scene right after when Senator Paine admits to his crimes is equally or even more powerful. This film is truly a masterpiece!

reply

Second of all, DWW is one of the greatest movies of all time.

reply

I agree, there are a lot of great scenes that lead up to an amazing climax.

The Senator Paine climax is extremely powerful. You can actually draw the Star Wars parallel of Darth Vader/A Skywalker. He realizes he has been corrupted and lets himself be destroyed in the end.

reply

That scene moves me so much everytime I see it, simply amazing!!!!!

"To days to come. All my love to long ago"

reply

It's an incredible scene...Stewart does some of the best acting of all time, and Claude Rains is terrific.

"I know you're in there, Fagerstrom!"-Conan O'Brien

reply

Almost 70 years old - and yet, even watching it now, simply amazing.

reply

The scene when Smith visits the monuments when he first arrives in Washington was even more moving for me. I don't know when I've ever felt prouder to be an American than when watching that scene.

the filibuster scene however, is also great

reply

I think the most moving scene for me is when Saunders finds him at the Lincoln memorial and convinces him to stay and fight. I get misty every time see it.

"Sarah Palin: Babies, guns, Jesus. Hot damn" Rush Limbaugh

reply

I agree, but I (being a female romantic fool) also like the dreamy eyed scenes with Saunders too. He's just talking about stuff he's always talked about, and she's never known anyone with such a pure heart, so she falls for him - love it!



"I have pills for everything. Some make you taller... some make you forget... "

reply

I rank Jimmy's filibuster scene as the greatest job by an actor in a single scene, along with Broderick Crawford"s "hicks" speech in "All the Kings Men," George C. Scott in the opening scene of "Patton," Gregory Peck in "To Kill a Mockingbird," Cagney flipping out in "White Heat," and Jimmy again in the final scene of ""It's A Wonderful Life." I just saw "Mr. Smith" again yesterday for the first time in years, and sat there totally STUNNED at Stewart's performance in the filibuster scene. A lot of the credit must be given to the director, Frank Capra who could get the best out of ANY actor, and especially Jimmy. He also directed him in "It's A Wonderful Life," again, to fabulous results.

reply

yeah, it is great. you cant really bash that scene.

Man, I don't drop character 'till I done the DVD commentary-Kirk Lazurus

reply

Jimmy Stewart was the greatest screen actor EVER.

reply

Absolutely! I watched this movie, once again, on TCM. I've seen it from beginning to end around five times. With each viewing, this movie grows and grows on me.

In particular, the scene you refer to, is an incredibly moving scene. Jimmy Stewart can carry off a scene like that and that makes him one of our all-time greatest actors, but the movie also had relevancy during that time, when backroom deals were more common place. The "Taylors" of the world were more prevalent back then.

That isn't to say things like that don't still persist in some shape or form (Political Action Committees and Special Interest Groups). However, I think the reason that scene, in which Jefferson Smith had exhausted all hope of shining the light on the truth, still has relevency is because of our notion, perceived or otherwise, that corruption still persists in government.

We hope that that our elected officials have the type of integrity and courage, like Jefferson Smith, to stand up for what we believe in.

It's a great scene and I can't help but tear up when I view it.

reply

Definitely. It resonates because the message hits home, that one man fighting for the right cause can make a difference, no matter the odds. And that no matter the odds, its always worth fighting for the right cause, never give up. Its what makes our country work. I love the scene.

reply

[deleted]

It is an absolutely sensational scene. The final speech he gives to Claude Rains is so heartbreaking and powerful. He is literally on his last legs and using his last breath, almost totally defeated, making this final impassioned plea to the man whom he knows is the only one that can save him.

Jimmy Stewart was beyond incredible, this was probably his finest hour as an actor. I could feel his pain, his devastation and how his spirit, although severly weakened has not yet broken.

And then, comes the ending, his vindication, and the feeling of joy is utterly immense.

*****************

reply


I agree with the OP -- possibly the greatest job by an actor in a single scene.

Absolutely stunning, and riveting.
.

reply