MovieChat Forums > The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1939) Discussion > Why was I not made of stone, like thee?

Why was I not made of stone, like thee?


When I first saw this remarkable film I was only a young child. It was one of those classics that was repeatedly aired on "Million Dollar Movie", on Channel 9 in New York City. In those formative years certain phrases, incidents and cultural phenomena have an intense impression on an eager mind, so much as to remain ingrained in not only the memory, but on an individual's entire weltanschauung ("world-view"). Of course, when Laughton speaks those words it's at the end of the film and thereby it naturally makes its impression more vividly than were they to be spoken randomly placed within the text of the script. But the depth of their meaning as well as the beauty in which Laughton expressed them made such an indelible impression on me I almost feel as if I had invented them myself out of the psychological impact that depression makes on a young mind. But Laughton's thespian acumen is so marvelous that his body language when he wraps his arm around the gargoyle and utters them is almost enough to deliver the meaning in its entirety even without listening to him recite them.
I was so enthralled with the early Renaissance portrayed in the sets and dialog I went on to major in Medieval and Northern Renaissance History and Art at University. This film is so auspicious I'm of the opinion that it stands out as one of the truly great works of art of the 20th century, in that cinema has established itself as a true art, new as a cultural phenomena that comprise a genuine art form. I feel privileged just to have seen it, in the way I feel blessed by viewing the works of Jan Van Eyck and all of the Northern Renaissance artists that introduced the seeds of our modern culture born out of Europe in that equally auspicious age of great beginnings.

reply

Beautifully said. You have a kindred spirit in me. And, Laughton's performance -- one of the finest ever recorded on film. The line, masterfully spoken, "Why was I not made of stone -- like these?", tears your heart out.

reply

You have another kindred spirit here as well. I have always loved this movie - even though it wrings your heart out. I was just watching the ending the other day and yes, when he says, "Why was I not made of stone-- like thee?" (checked it with captions too) I have always felt a queer connection with that sentiment and the magnificent way he delivers it. It really is something we have all felt at one time or another in our lives - yet we keep on keeping on. As Maya Angelou would say, in that lies the nobility of the human race.

Great movie - words really aren't enough. :)

reply

Me, too. I watched this a number of times on our Award Theater in the 50s and 60s. It went a long way in teaching me compassion for others, much more so than the church. I grew up with a friend who had some birth defects and he was about as good a person as you'd ever be fortunate to know. As we got to our adolescence, he had a big crush on a girl who was rather popular - but she was not interested in him. He mostly suffered in silence except with a few close friends. I thought about him a lot when I'd watch this movie. It was a hard but vital lesson to learn about the inner beauty that matters more so much more than the cover.

When I got into my 20's, I had this "love" for someone who wouldn't give me the time of day. I once found myself wondering: "Why was I not made of stone-- like thee?" I shared it with my friend and he just smiled and nodded.

reply

That is such an awesome story - and one that I can relate to. I am not deformed or "ugly" - just overweight. I've struggled with my weight since adolescence and I have often felt rebuffed by those that were luckier than I in the "genetic lottery."

I have listened while many a friend, who was a male, recounted to me the horrible treatment of so called "beautiful" women more times than I can count.
As I have listened, sometimes the guy having no clue I liked him, I've thought many times, can you not see the quality of the compassionate person before you??

Yeah, I too am nodding with you. :)

reply

Kindred spirits we are.

Saw about a third of it this morning from where Q begs for water and E gives him some to where Frollo confesses his murder of Phoebus to Claude. Looking forward to watching the last part tonight. But the end line will always strike a chord with me.

Regards to you.

reply

In the immortal words of Sam Wheat, "Ditto!"

Yes, I too saw it was on TCM (I like how this year they are doing it by the studio - Enchanted Cottage is another RKO movie that is special to me) so I recorded it on my DVR too. Watched part on my lunch, looking forward to finishing it tonight.

Many happy regards to you too, mon ami! :)

reply

Yes, Enchanted Cottage is another great, sweet film. A good lesson for all. I really like Herbert Marshall's role as someone who cannot judge by looks but by the person's character, heart and personality.

reply

Very well said, everyone.

I think I've only seen the film once, about 15-20 years ago.

But this line has stuck with me.

I watched it with my mom and I believe she teared up.

The line is also relatable when you are homeless and can't possibly make a relationship happen.

reply

One of the very great closing lines of film IMO.

reply

[deleted]