Well, unsurprising, considering he is really the great tragic hero of the novel... The film changes him a lot because the Hays Code prevented bringing the clergy into 'disrepute'.
He's heartbreaking in the book - like something out of Dostoevskii: a tormented young priest (he's only in his mid-30s), a brilliant scholar and scientist, destroyed and destroying because he can't cope with the conflict between his desires as a man and his vows of celibacy. Unfortunately, the Catholic Legion of Decency would have had a fit if the film had shown him as he was written by Victor Hugo! And I'm not sure which of the leading men in Hollywood at the time could have brought off the role. (Leslie Howard? He'd been a good stage Hamlet, and I think some of the same qualities are needed for this role.) Claude's just incredibly intense, and... well, ahem! You get the picture... ;-D
reply
share