the ending--Help


I just turned this on in time to see the ending where Claude Rains and Mickey are leaving on a train.

Mickey didn't committ suicide did he? Or was this heaven? Help!!

reply

What you saw was the ending to DAUGHTERS COURAGEOUS.

For some reason, TCM stuck the film DAUGHTERS COURAGEOUS between FOUR DAUGHTERS
and its sequel, FOUR WIVES. DAUGHTERS COURAGEOUS has the same cast with a similar premise--Claude Rains has four adult daughters, then John Garfield shows
up as "Mr. Wrong." Despite the similarities, DAUGHTERS COURAGEOUS has nothing
to do with the "FOUR..." series.

At the end of FOUR DAUGHTERS, Mickey, feeling that he has trapped his wife in
an unhappy marriage, indeed commits suicide. To make the ending even more cruel,
Priscilla Lane's character, after a VERY brief mourning period, starts hanging
around with Felix Dietz again. Oh well, life goes on. The End.

But is it? The sequel begins with Priscilla's character already engaged to
Felix when she learns that she is pregnant--with Mickey's baby! So apparently
she couldn't give poor Mickey a proper period of mourning before she went
Felix-hunting (say, more than 2 months?). A little cold, huh?

Then there's that whole business of palming off the adopted baby on the other
sister, but I won't go into that. This series tends to have a cruel streak
which spoils it.


I'm not crying, you fool, I'm laughing!

reply

[deleted]

If he didn't kill himself, he lost his mind--he had a crazy look as his car sped out of control, and then we saw his foot going down on the gas pedal.

There are plot points in this movie that don't make sense--the whole Emma in love with Felix thing, so his sister won't marry Felix. Then Emma marries the lunkhead.

There's a big jump from the Ann/Felix engagement scene to the scene with Mickey and Ann in the park. It's kind of jarring--I think a scene must have been cut.

But the movie is pretty near irresistable, isn't it?

reply

It's irresistible in the sense that I would have loved to be one of the four
daughters, sitting around every evening playing music with the adorable Claude
Rains as my dad, May Robson as my gruff aunt, and cuddly Frank McHugh as my
husband, and living in that quaint little town. I just think the disposal of
John Garfield's character was cruel.

I'm not crying, you fool, I'm laughing!

reply

I love Four Daughters. I have never been able to find the original Fannie Hurst story called Sister Act which was published in Cosmopolitan magazine and was the basis of Four Daughters -- it's entirely possible the Mickey Borden character was disposed of by Fannie Hurst.

reply

Tearose. I found a copy of the original story through Interlibrary Loan, from a college in Iowa. The only reason I saw it at all was because of a favour from my Library's Reference Head. I couldn't make copies, and it had to be back after three days. I sent it back after one...

I can tell you this, I found it a waste of paper. It bore no resemblance to FOUR DAUGHTERS except the names. The Lemp girls were identical QUADRUPLETS, for Gosh sakes. I think Felix and Mickey were in it, but I can't remember any reference to Ernest or Ben. Also, Ann DIES!!!

The FOUR DAUGHTERS that we love so well, are solely the creation of the Wonderful Epstein brothers at Warners....

reply

Yet another case of a film adaptation being superior to a weak book/story.

reply