MovieChat Forums > La grande illusion (1938) Discussion > This dropped out of the imdb top 250

This dropped out of the imdb top 250


Proof that user interaction has turned this website into garbage.

reply

Too bad.

- Who is God ?
- When you close your eyes and make a wish, God is the one who doesn't care about.

reply

i voted this movie a 6. I'm glad that this movie is out of the 250. It's simply very overrated.

Ash: [for no apparent reason] ... Groovy.

reply

Yeah, get this trash out of Top 250, we need to make way for more Batman movies or another Pirates of the Caribbean flick.
---

reply

meh, the top 250 is worthless anyway.

Last film seen: Tenacious D in The pick of Destiny 8/10

reply

Last film seen: Tenacious D in The pick of Destiny 8/10

now it's 6,8...

reply

An unpopular opinion isn't always a wrong opinion. Only losers give movies high ratings because they are already established to have them.

Last film seen: The General 7/10

reply

The dominate age group of IMDb skews young. That pretty much means anything B&W or with subtitles doesn't get a fair shake.

Their lost.

Actually, I'm glad because trolls tend to stay away from quality movies I like.



No two persons ever watch the same movie.

reply

Shame indeed. But there is something strange about "La Grande Illusion". Its note is 8. Therefore, it should be in Top 250, between 178 and 230. But it does not appear anywhere ?

reply

For the top 250 only the votes of "regualr voters" are counted and IMDB does not disclose what criteria is uses to determine who is a "regular voter." The 8 it has scored and is shown on its IMDB page is the score from all voters.

reply

IMDB's top 250 lost any credibility it may have still had when the movie "300" made the list BEFORE it even opened. Since then it has become little more than a dumping ground for the latest fan boy fixation.

reply

Artistic viewpoints in appreciating and understanding the beauty behind such a classic is diminishing, thanks to the media power of studios in advertising blockbuster junk for monetary reasons. Unfortunately, it's all about making money that movies such La Grande illusion are neglected by this new generation.

"I told you to keep away from that radio. If that battery is dead it'll have company." Cody Jarrett

reply

do not be so cynical, there are still many of us who understand it's significance and artistic quality.

reply

and.now.it's.back.for.a.while.let's.hope.it.stays.there.

My.Top.10.Films
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ghQeEmz3Dt4

reply

many foreign movies should be in the list

Werner Herzog,Andrey Tarkovskiy,Robert Bresson,Jean Renoir,Jean-Luc Godard
Luis Buñuel and Krzysztof Kieslowski .

all these great directors their movies not in the top 250
and you called it imdb top 250.

Top 250 = Big joke.

reply

[deleted]

yes I'm with you brother
1-dances with wolves
2-kes
3-bolwup
4-if
5-midnight cowboy
6-the last picture show
7-easy rider
8-The Ox-Bow Incident
9-a man escaped
10-band of outsider
11-Hiroshima mon amour

my favorite films://www.imdb.com/list/iFa7p7uwsr8/

reply

the top 250 is worthless

reply

TOP 250 does not represent 250 best movie. It represents 250 most popular movies.

---------------------------------------------
Applied Science? All science is applied. Eventually.

reply

I am sure one day it will return.


It's that man again!!

reply