Shutter Island?


Anyone see the huge similarities in the shot selection/religious undertones in this and on the Shutter Island trailer? I know Scorsese is a huge P and P fan; the shots of Leo on the cliff are almost directly taken out of the scene where the man(I forget the name, dammit) falls off. Plus, the usual Scorsese touches in Religious symbolism are apparent in the Shutter Island trailer and mirror the church scenes in TEofTW.

Btw, pretty decent movie, granted this being a first Powell/Pressberger major film. Soviet montage is definitely in influence in the editing.

Too bad Shutter Island got pushed back until February;(

reply

Btw, pretty decent movie, granted this being a first Powell/Pressberger major film.

This was made before Powell met Pressburger. But it was Powell's first really personal film and was the start of the collaborations that led to The Archers. Some of the people in EotW were still being used in later Powell & Pressburger films.

Eric Berry (Robbie Manson, the one that fell off the cliff), was Lermontov's assistant in The Red Shoes and various other films
John Laurie (Peter Manson) was in Colonel Blimp
Finlay Currie (James Gray) was in I Know Where I'm Going!
Various members of the crew carried on working with Powell for many years as well.

Remember that none of these people had multi-film contracts with the studios. They were all hired for just one film at a time. But many of them would go out of their way to work on a project with The Archers


Some others have commented about the use of cliffs in the Shutter Island trailer and wondered in Scorsese is deliberately referencing EotW. I'm not sure about that, but the shot near the end of the trailer with Leo running up the spiral staircase is a deliberate tip of the hat to The Red Shoes

Steve

reply

< I'm not sure about that, but the shot near the end of the trailer with Leo running up the spiral staircase is a deliberate tip of the hat to The Red Shoes

Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh....I do see where you're getting at, although I think it was a nod to Carol Reed's "The Third Man" with the dutch angle ala at the end where Harry Lime as he climbs the staircase, but I definitely see how you got The Red Shoes having just saw it recently.

reply

Also that Scorsese and Thelma Schoonmaker told me that it was The Red Shoes that they were thinking of when they shot it and cut it like that
http://www.powell-pressburger.org/Trips/Cannes/20090515/Report.html

Steve

reply