MovieChat Forums > A Day at the Races (1937) Discussion > So fed up with racial complaints

So fed up with racial complaints


I'm getting so sick and tired of reading reviews for old films and hearing endless moanings about racism, stereotypes and endless other politically correct stuff that is spoiling films which I used to enjoy.
There might be fair points at times, and since I'm not American, such supposed issues mightn't affect me as much on a personal level, but there are plenty of ridiculous arguments as well (someone accused the 1932 "Dr Jeckyll And Mr Hyde" of racism because Mr Hyde looked black), and has me rethinking coming to this site and reading other people's views, something I would normally enjoy

reply

[deleted]

Sorry you don't like the dialog here. Maybe it would be better if you stuck to the threads that didn't contain the words "race", "racial", "stereotype", "caricature", or "segregation" in the titles. [this list should not be assumed to be exhaustive]

This might alleviate some of your "sickness."



dolceri ac dolcere

reply

These race-card playing liberal cry babies live in the past, and honestly think an 80 year old film represents 2011 America. (Forgive the grammatical error, I used liberal and think in the same sentence).

reply

I know that I was alarmed when BIRTH OF A NATION was first attacked for its portrayal of African-Americans. Yes, those scenes were deplorable, but I feel the movies should stand. They portray American attitudes of the days and while they are not "politically correct", they do give us understanding of those days. I personally am one of those disappointed that it's practically impossible now to find "Amos and Andy" radio shows. That program was actually an advancement in portraying African-Americans as families often facing the same challenges as everyone else.

I'm the kind of guy, when I move - watch my smoke. But I'm gonna need some good clothes though.

reply

Believe it or not. I believe I had heard while watching TCM that someone tried to show Birth Of A Nation some time ago and was prevented due to the backlash. It was a short comment like they often do before & after films. not sure who told this story but the theater was in LA.

reply

I personally believe that BIRTH OF A NATION should be shown so that audiences of today can see for themselves what the general attitude of white Americans toward black Americans was at the time.

Life, every now and then, behaves as though it had seen too many bad movies

reply

[deleted]

As a white woman I think it's my right -- no, my DUTY -- to whine endlessly about the fact my great-grandmothers were denied the vote, college educations, and that {gasp!} careers outside the home were rare.

I choose to be bitter.

With the help of liberals in academia and the media, I'll keep telling myself that we females continue to be powerless, 2nd class citizens while ignoring the fact that we're now CEOs, elected to Congress, and can even become viable presidential candidates.

Yep, I'm going to make sure those embers of injustice from long ago are constantly stoked to ignite anger in the next generation of women who will find their identity in victim-hood instead of self-reliance. [/racial analogy]


And the dead shall be raised incorruptible,and we shall be changed.~1 Corinthians 15:52

reply

I personally believe that BIRTH OF A NATION should be shown so that audiences of today can see for themselves what the general attitude of white Americans toward black Americans was at the time.


Actually, BIRTH OF A NATION was controversial even back in 1915! It was not shown in several parts of the country. NAACP called out on it. Rioting even broke out in major cities where it was playing. It was the first movie to play in the White House, but as it was discovered later, Woodrow Wilson actually dismissed it, calling it "an unfortunate product".

reply

Actually, you should take a look at "Birth of a Nation" sometime -- it is indeed HIDEOUSLY racist. The racial stuff in "A Day at the Races" (ironic title?), by contrast, is actually just kind of silly. It's dated as hell and looks pretty foolish today, but you really have to be a professsional grievance-monger to get worked up about it.

For something to be really offensive, I think, it needs to be actually hateful -- like "Birth of a Nation" -- not just dopey.

And if you can't get over that dumb song and just enjoy the rest of the movie -- which is superb -- well, I feel kind of sorry for you.

reply