i wonder how many 'the incredibles' fans will vote 1 for this movie .

I voted 9 for The Incredibles and 7 for Modern Times. Now, I'm an avid fan of silent cinema, but for me The Incredibles is simply a better film - wittier, more interesting, and a lot more entertaining. It’s a truly brilliant film, but I guess some people automatically look down on animated films, regardless of their actual merits. BTW, I only gave 9 to two other films this year, and one of them is incidentally a Chaplin film - Limelight (not a typical Chaplin, but the most moving film I’ve seen in a very long time).

It actually makes sense that I like a film like The Incredibles better than I do Modern Times, because as a Keaton fan, I much prefer non-stop action and gags to pathos. In this regard, Limelight wasn’t in-your-face Chaplin-pathos; it was more subtle than that. Notwithstanding this, Modern Times was much better than all the Keaton & Arbuckle shorts I've seen last week, so I'm not complaining :-)

Prog.

Jeez, can you say "pretentious"...?

Has it ever occurred to you that people may like both "The Incredibles" and "Modern Times"?

In my system, 7 is mediocre, 8 is good or above average, 9 is excellent, and anything rated 10 is virtually immune to opposition on my part. I gave The Incredibles 10. This film came very close to being a 10.

I also voted 9 for Rear Window and The Matrix Reloaded. :-P

The cockroach is a noble beast....

9 to the Incredibles, 10 to this!

Also, I gave a 10 to Wall*E. :P

Both 10 from me ;)

What does liking The Incredibles have to do with disliking Modern Times? I thoroughly enjoyed both, but for very different reasons.

THE INCREDIBLES: 10/10
MODERN TIMES: 8/10