God, John Ford certainly knew how to compose a shot, didn't he? The noirish and expressionistic photography is stunningly beautiful. Of course, it'd mean nothing if it weren't in service of a great story - 10/10.
I agree that the shots were beautiful, but I have to say I was really disappointed in this film. I expected more out of a Ford film, especially one that won 4 oscars. I didn't think the portrayal of King Gypo deserved a best actor oscar, and the script was overrated. This was by far the most overhyped and overrated John Ford film I've seen so far.
Catfish-everyone is entitled to their opinion...but,I think much must be considered before passing judgement. The most obvious would be the movie is almost 80yrs old. That considered,I'd say the movie has held up.