MovieChat Forums > Manhattan Melodrama (1934) Discussion > Slocum Disaster in Beginning

Slocum Disaster in Beginning


I liked the first half of the movie, then it turned corny, but I understand that it was like that in that era. The beginning hooked me when I saw the name on that boat. That really happened, but worse. The Slocum fire led to a big trial, which the movie did not get into. The ship was owned by rich men who bribed officials, and none of the lifejackets worked, although they had passed numerous inspections. The jackets were so old that people wearing them were actually weighed down and sank. I think the majority of people who died, if not all, were German immigrants. Great beginning to the film, especially the way they nailed the speech patterns of people and the way they dressed.

reply

I didn't care for the first 20 mediocre minutes, but continued watching it nevertheless as a friend recommended the film and then thought it got a little better, so I rated it 4 stars. Considering the fact that it was directed by W. S. Van Dyke who directed "The Thin Man" I was disappointed. A rather mediocre film. Not a keeper. And definitely not worth to be watched a second time. You can tell this was made in the early thirties which is not nearly as obvious in the Thin Man movies. They are much more sophisticated.


reply

I think the comedies of the era were far more adult than the dramas. The dramas were almost cartoonish, with histrionic acting. The best comedies were sophisticated and still hold up today, acting and dialogue.I enjoy this, though, because of Powell and Loy.

reply