MovieChat Forums > Hold Your Man (1933) Discussion > Hold Your Man is excellent!

Hold Your Man is excellent!


I really enjoyed this movie. It had it all sex, intensity, and passion. Jean was excellent. She was very sexy in the beginning then became serious towards the middle and end of the movie. I like her punching scene, she showed she had guts. Jean proved she was more then just a sexpot. I was impressed by her performance. She was very believeable and intensity of the movie brought tears to my eyes, the movies today couldn't capture that type of intensity and passion.

Another person of the movie that moved me was gorgeous black actress Theresa Harris, who appeared with more stars then anyone and a few times she got her time to shine without being sterotyped, for an era where black actors/actresses were forced to play demeaning parts, Theresa was as equal on screen as the white actress as a jail mate. People talk of Lena Horne and Dorothy Dandridge but not Theresa who has an impressive movie resume. I'm glad MGM wanted to show reality and gave Theresa a chance. I guess that would only happen in the pre-code era. The black actor who played Theresa's father who was a pastor was very moving when he married Jean and Clark. I heard on TCM that the particular scene where Clark and Jean are married by the preacher was actually reshot with a white pastor to show, I guess, down south for the racists who didn't want to see blacks in prominent parts and mixing with whites. The scene with the black preacher was definitely more moving and I'm glad that scene wasn't cut and is shown. Theresa was also great with Barbara Stanwyck in Babyface and with Ginger Rogers in Professional Sweetheart. After the pre-code era she was seen more then heard.

All the actresses in the movie was great, especially Dorothy Burgess, she usually always played the bitch in movies and played it well, sad she didn't become a bigger star, she's mostly forgotten now.

I know from reading about Clark (and his wife Carole) that he wasn't prejudice or anything like, he would go out his way to show kindness to people of color, and I think that's what made the particular scene with the black preacher so real. He was friends with Hattie McDaniels and I think that came across on screen. Does anyone know what was Jean's view on people of color? I remember seeing a documentary on her and a photo was shown with her as a child and there was a black man, I guess a servant or something who was next to her. I wondered who he was. Blues legend Leadbelly sung a song dedicated to Jean when she passed. I thought that was very nice that a black singer would dedicate a song to her in that time era.

reply

Was an excellent movie, saw it on TCM on Jan 11/09, ive never seen a Jean Harlow movie before, now i want to see all her films!
Loved that line especially, "I'm the Queen of Sheba"

reply


http://www.last.fm/music/Leadbelly/_/Jean+Harlow

"I'm issuing a restraining order: Religion must stay 500 yards away from Science at all times!!"

reply

I've always loved this movie - one of the two or three best Harlow films that's not an acknowledged classic.

reply

I caught this one again this afternoon and enjoyed it.I loved how it started off sharp and snappy and stayed that way almost to the end when you could really feel MGM pouring on the smaltz.I can't help but wonder if Warner Brothers would have handled it the same way.

reply

I love "Hold Your Man" it's sadly underrated and it needs to be released on DVD. Not only did I love Harlow and Gable (they were great separately and as a team)but the supporting cast was excellent. I have to say my favorite of the reformatory inmates was socialist Sadie. I love how she managed to make copies of the keys to isolation using the sewing machines! I know MGM is more known for glamorous, glossy productions, but this one was really gritty and realistic in many ways. It's a great movie, hands down!

reply

ms lady soul i couldnt agree with you more .this film had everything give credit to anita loos who wrote the story and screen play. how wonderful and ground breaking to have harlow and gable married by an african american preacher.love knows no colors. you should check out other anita loos screenplays such as San Fransisco 1937 Saratoga 1937 The Women 1939 . if you watch the film "The Women " you wont realize until after the film that there was not 1 male actor in the entire movie . have a great day

reply

Yea, but regarding "The Women", I realized while watching the film the subject of most of the ladies conversations WERE males!

reply

Theresa Harris is great in one of the few roles where she is not a domestic servant.
While the script lets her be a real person, the role she plays is probably still a sexist and racist stereotype from that era - she's a convict who describes herself as having been put in jail by her own father because of her promiscuity.

reply