MovieChat Forums > Rich and Strange (1932) Discussion > 2 moments that require explaining

2 moments that require explaining


I never saw this movie till last night. I loved it and was totally blown away by it.

I had trouble with two things.

1) There are no lifeboats or rescues ships present as the ocean liner sinks. Just a junk with scavengers.

2) When Commander Gordon and Emily Hill are in a car and he is bad mouthing the Princess, the editing sequence appeared jumbled and awkward. At one point she looks down at the running board of the car to watch road go by. I know Hitchcock is extremely meticulous with his movies, but this went over my head.



Smoke me a kipper. I’ll be back for breakfast

reply

[deleted]

1) I don't know if there were lifeboats or not, but I believe there were. All the crew and passengers have departed, you'll notice, when our happy couple finally get on deck. My guess is that they took all the lifeboats, assuming that all survivors were present. Just a guess, but I'm sticking with it. Rescue ships are those available to answer distress calls. It may be there were no ships around in the hours from the damage to when our couple gets out onto the deck. It's a big ocean out there. My quandary is where the lifeboats are, if the crew and passengers were able to cast off in them. You'd think they'd be around the ship, where all the rescue ships would be heading. I'll say it's just a script device to have our heroes left alone on board.

2) This is a bad movie, in my very humble opinion. The editing was bad, and the sound editing was horrible. When the commander and Emily are in the car, some of their scenes are shot in the back seat, but some are clearly in a studio set with a black background. It was very amateurish. Much of the editing was amateurish. It's interesting to see the master Hitchcock learning his craft, but overall this is a bad movie.

reply

[deleted]

Movie girl: I really liked the film and thought they were rescued by the people in the Chinese junk. There was the sound of a newborn crying, etc. amid the rescue. But one wonders about fellow passengers.

Also, it was good, but clearance is difficult in the end. She had not cheated, only at heart. But he had, with the woman who pretended to have a title. "Princess".

AT the end they got back together - he was back to his monotonous job and she to the sewing. Then we see that she is expecting. Both are joyful with the news.

reply

I was pretty blown away too! It's a little gem of a film.

1) When they come out of the cabin after waking Fred calls, "Ahoy!". Emily asks, "Have they gone, Fred?" and Fred replies, "... Of course they've gone." Clearly the lifeboats had left the previous evening. There's no reason for them to hang around or risk their lives checking for stray passengers on a sinking ship.

2) I don't think it's jumbled; Emily is shown looking down towards the running board and then we see her POV. Looking away from the Commander shows her interest is waning in him and that her thoughts are elsewhere. The fast-passing road beneath symbolises how she feels Fred is quickly escaping her. Moments later she asks for the car to be stopped and leaves the Commander. I think it's a very simple and elegant insert.

reply

The ship that sinks wasn't an ocean liner, it was a cargo ship that took on passengers for some extra money. It was one of those ships that always shows up in Charlie Chan movies. Remember when Fred says they have enough money to get home on a cheap boat. I'm guessing that the crew wasn't too concerned for the safety of the passengers.

reply