MovieChat Forums > The Lost Squadron (1932) Discussion > A pictorial history of flipping-the-bird

A pictorial history of flipping-the-bird


This old flick might be the first recorded instance of someone flipping the bird. And boy, did Robt Armstrong relish the act. Not content to only stick up his finger, he threw his whole arm into it, pointedly jabbing the hand up and down and smiling the whole time.
I had it on TiVo:
"Hey, honey, come here."
Bored and distracted, Mrs Swift-12 drags herself into the room, no doubt thinking, "What dopey old movie is this fool blabbering about now?"
"Lookit this."
[*flip*]
Mrs Swift-12: "HAHAHAHA!"

Previously I'd always thought the earliest instance was BATTLE CRY, a 1950's Van Heflin war movie where they inserted some real footage of troops. (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0047860/board/nest/24840318) The camera car filming them was passing by a long line of soldiers relaxing on the ground, and one of them stuck his finger up at the camera. Evidently the film-makers didn't notice THAT when they chose this stock footage.


Btw, I was hoping for more from LOST SQUADRON. More intensity in the flying sequences for instance. Those old open-cockpit biplanes should make for the most photogenic aerial footage, but I've seen better.
Meanwhile, the performances were laughably dated and stiff, except for Joel McCrea. Richard Dix and Robt Armstrong were particularly bad. (Except for that joyful bird-shot.)

There is one other plus -- the theme deals with how our heroes from WWI had difficulty adjusting to civilian life. One day they're the toast of the nation; soon they are misfits. The first half of the movie really felt like THE BEST YEARS OF OUR LIVES, which more successfully covered this theme for the WWII vets. Offhand, besides THE LOST SQUADRON I can think of no other film about WWI vets that closely approaches BEST YEARS.


||||||
||||||

reply

An interesting historical study!

In "The Miracle Woman" starring Barbara Stanwyck and Directed by Frank Capra, the chauffeur comes out of a room after an argument with someone, turns around and gives a hearty finger towards the door he has just closed. This movie was released in 1931, predating "The Lost Squadron" by a year.

reply

Thanks for the tip.
Makes me wonder when and how the gesture really began.

In other cultures they have other insults, like biting the thumb.

||||||
||||||

reply


Armstrong makes no gesture in this movie. Dix does, to Armstrong. And it's not flipping the bird, which would be an upright gesture. He's jerking his finger downward; its also no clear whether its the index or middle finger.




Absurdity: A Statement or belief inconsistent with my opinion.

reply

Sorry, but you are making a fool of yourself adamantly denying this fact on two separate threads. Armstong DID flip the bird. Not sure why you are in such deep denial about it. Of course, I don't expect you to take my word for it so ...
http://immortalephemera.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/35-robert-armstrong.jpg

reply

Your link doesn't work.

Look, I apologize if I've offended you; if you provide a link that works, I'll retract my statement.





Absurdity: A Statement or belief inconsistent with my opinion.

reply

You didn't offend me. Your adamant denial of the scene just seemed odd. Very odd. It's there. Always has been. The link will work with a little fines or Google it.

reply

You were right. I was wrong.





Absurdity: A Statement or belief inconsistent with my opinion.

reply

Got to love pre-code!
Robert Armstrong did look like he was relishing it though.

Although Harold Lloyd predates him by a few years.
http://s669.photobucket.com/user/gudsrost/media/Harold-Lloyd-flips-the-bird-2.jpg.html

reply

This is the third Pre-Code film I've seen with the middle finger. The first I've seen was "Parachute Jumper" from 1933. The film starred Doug Fairbanks, Jr. and Frank McHugh showed the finger. Later, I came across Harold Lloyd(!)giving himself the finger in a fun-house mirror. The film is "Speedy" from 1928. Another film I've seen, but didn't notice the "offensive" action, is "The Miracle Woman" with Barbara Stanwyck. I'll look better next time.

If I had choice of weapons with you, sir, I'd choose grammar.

reply