Roy's Family


If Myra hadn't died in the air raid, and she had gone on to continue her engagement with Roy...what do you think his family (the Major, mom & sister) would have done? Would they have been good sports about their 19 year old son marrying a hooker, or would they have butted in and stopped things.

Also, how do you think Roy would have handled things? The landlady tells him how she earns her bread, and he is furious with her...but still loves her. Would family pressure have been the end of Roy & Myra?

reply

I'm sure informing mom that she was a prostitute would take its toll very soon. That Bette Davis character could turn into a bitch so easily...

Roy really doesn't care, but I doubt he's independent enough to go against his family.

_____________________
Tally-ho, my fine saucy young trollop!

reply

My thinking as well. Roy would have been fine for awhile, but I think eventually the gaffe would have been too great for a society boy such as he. Divorce, although scandalous in the 1930s, might have been preferable for the Cronin family in this case. I feel sure if Myra & Roy had been parents, the Cronins would have wanted to have custody, and bring up the kid in Roy's lifestyle.

reply

I guess that's why they had to bump her off at the end.

reply

Alix1929 says > If Myra hadn't died in the air raid, and she had gone on to continue her engagement with Roy...what do you think his family (the Major, mom & sister) would have done?
The relationship between Myra and Roy would never work. There are many reason but the main one is Myra herself. She doesn't feel worthy and looks down on herself. As much as she'd love to leave her life behind and step into Roy's life, she knows she'd never fit. She's only comfortable in her own environment with her friends.

When she tells Roy's mother about herself, she's hoping she will end the relationship. Myra does care for Roy and doesn't want to hurt him. He's been kind and accepting of her. His mother though knows he's a rescuer. If she or anyone goes against Myra, Roy will only swoop in to the rescue. As she tells Myra, they understand each other. That means his mother knows that Myra knows she's way out of her league. Even if they accepted her, she could never fit into their family.


Woman, man! That's the way it should be Tarzan. [Tarzan and his mate]

reply

I disagree. If that idiot Major could fit into the family, then surely Myra, with her looks and intelligence and love of her husband, could too!

reply

jawebster2000 says > I disagree. If that idiot Major could fit into the family, then surely Myra, with her looks and intelligence and love of her husband, could too!
As I said the main reason Myra wouldn't fit is because she'd never be comfortable. Perhaps at some point in time that may change but at the point when she died she was still full of insecurities and self-doubt. People who have those issues tend to self-sabotage.

Even if Roy and the family bent over backwards in order to make her feel welcome and a part of the family (which in itself would be a problem), she'd find ways to 'prove' they really didn't like her or want her around. Eventually, they probably would be fed up, especially if they had been making all kinds of concessions on her behalf.

I'm not sure why you think the Major or Myra's looks and intelligence factor into the equation. Those things, I think, support my point. The Major seemed the bumbling type but that may have been due to his age. He was, as I recall, a titled upper crust Brit so he could have been a lunatic, it wouldn't have mattered. Titles and status pass from father to eldest son in under that system.

That said, he married Roy's mother, an American, and accepted her family as his. That would have taken some adjustment so it shows a willingness to embrace outsiders. The fact Myra was, as you said, attractive and intelligent and Roy loved her means she could fit in. Unfortunately, that does not mean she would.


Woman, man! That's the way it should be Tarzan. [Tarzan and his mate]

reply