MovieChat Forums > M - Eine Stadt sucht einen Mörder (1931) Discussion > Can you explain the last 5-10 minutes to...

Can you explain the last 5-10 minutes to me?


I watched the 1hr50min cut of the film and was a little confused by the last few minutes.

reply

The entire criminal underworld is ready to tear Peter Lorre's character apart because his crimes against children are the most despicable imaginable even among thieves, whores, etc., But his lawyer argues if he was crazy, as was suggested by his story of the only time he doesn't hear voices telling him to kill was WHEN he was killing, then it's not his fault, his appointed lawyer and the rest of the kangaroo court barter back and forth on where his accountability lies, but the rest of the court doesn't care, so they get ready to charge him and kill him, and that's when the police come in and bust them all, and he's carted off for a real trial, where it doesn't matter what the verdict is, if it's not guilty by insanity, guilty, guilty with a life sentence, guilty with a death sentence, it is irrelevant because no verdict is going to bring the dead children back to life, and the only thing that's going to prevent other people from committing more murders is the parents watching their children instead of just trusting they'll be fine.

reply

[deleted]

The ending isn't ambiguous. The judge puts on a black cap just before pronouncing sentence; the black cap indicated a sentence of death was coming.

reply

Thx for the clarification. I was a bit confused by the ending as well.

reply

I'm not certain about that point.

While it was common for a black cap to be worn when pronouncing a death sentence in England and Wales I can't find any source that it was the case in Germany.

Everything I can find looks like they're just dressed in the usual attire of Weimar Republic judges.

reply

The movie pointedly shows him putting on the black cap. It's not ambiguous.

reply

The question is whether a black cap was used in 1931 Germany only during death sentences.

Most pictures of judges from the Weimar Republic show them wearing hats regardless of the judgement.

reply

The picture shows the judge putting on a black cap, then pronouncing sentence. It's not complicated. It's not a documentary; Lang was an artist.

reply

Once again, the question is whether there is any reason to think that a black cap being worn only to pronounce a death sentence applies here.

The only sources I have found say that such a custom existed in England and Wales, but mention no other countries. Most pictures show judges in Weimar-era Germany wearing hats as part of their normal attire.

reply

The question is why does Lang choose to show the judge putting on a black cap? Of all the things Lang can show, he shows that. The sentence is death.

reply

The answer is no then, you do not have a source or any reason to believe this.

That wasn't so hard to admit.

Have a wonderful day!

reply