MovieChat Forums > Der blaue Engel (1930) Discussion > How is this a political allegory?

How is this a political allegory?


Most reviews say the Heinrich Mann book "Professor Unrat" on which this film is based is fierce social criticism, satirizing things like the middle class and the educational system. Even the film itself was accused at the time of being an 'allegory' about pre-war Germany.

But these days the social criticism seems very minor (or at least awfully well hidden). During my several viewings of the film the possibility of some sort of allegory or political criticism never even occurred to me.

Why is there "nothing to see here"? Have the times changed that much, or was the film adaptation greatly softened, or am I not seeing the forest for the trees, or what???

reply

All I can come up with is how desperate people (Rath) are drawn to powerful, charismatic personalities (Lola) who will use and ruin them. Then consider the time and place, and the political party gaining momentum.

reply

I mean, what point don't you understand? Though don't expect a 'modern' straightforward politically correct and clearly pinpointing allegory.
(That's why I love mostly old movies: for their subtlety!)

Just ask yourself about the social classes, and ask yourself, who in the whole plot is at ease, in a positive state of mind, with perspectives? This isn't Rath, who lingers in a ritualistic existence, with his maid. Lonely, with little dedication to teach the pupils. The pupils, mostly disinterested, or a boot-licker, wasting their time in a cabaret. The whole troop, a sad clown (!), with the troop as last resort, a boss, who panders to the honorable professor, an old drunkard 'captain', a bored audience who try to get a glance at women's legs (something their their wives probably withheld), and on top a singer, who is more of a visual prostitute. She has a heart, she loves the bird (hers is still alive), she has the puppet, and mostly loves to be adored.
Neither has the chance to realize their aspirations, everyone seems stuck in a social context, be it high or low, little to no chance to meet people from another classes constructively.
Josef von Sternberg offers us a wonderful setting and cinematography showing exactly that: how everyone lives in their own little prison cell. The cells are there, clearly marked, and yet invisible.

reply

I really enjoy it when somebody responds in essence "that's a stupid question, and you must be stupid or you wouldn't have asked it". Thanks very much.

I still don't get it. The references to _societal_ allegory I get ...and got. The society is stupidly stratified, full of unhappy people, and constructed so that even more unhappiness is likely.

It's the references to _political_ allegory I don't get. Where is there any reference to any government or election or relations with another country or future wars or...?

reply

There are some people who see their own political and social outlook validated in whatever they look at. I can't see any of either in Blue Angel --- except that, not far down the road, most of the boys in the Professor's class were certainly going to make good little Nazis!

-------

He maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good... St. Matthew 5:45

reply