MovieChat Forums > The Canary Murder Case Discussion > Silent and sound versions were combined

Silent and sound versions were combined


They remade this film, originally silent, as a sound picture. Problem is, Louise Brooks scarpered to Europe after the silent versin was made. So the actors in the original had to loop their dialogue (not very good synching on their part), but Paramount had to use a voice actress to do Loiuse's dialogue. It was as if whiney-voiced Lina Lamont was looping Kathy Selden's dialogue in "Singin' in the Rain." Whatever actress did the dubbing must have been the girlfriend of some executive, ie, she was not hired because her voice reminded anyone of Helen Hayes or Ethel Barrymore.

reply

Margaret Livingston was a highly-respected actress, and not the girlfriend of some movie executive. Hello, the Harlowesque voice is in perfect keeping with the character of a blackmailing show-girl, who is no Katherine Cornell, Jeanne Eagels, or Lynn Fontanne.

reply