MovieChat Forums > Show People (1928) Discussion > To Each His or Her Own

To Each His or Her Own


I love a lot of silent movies, but this was unbearable to me. The music was so bad my eyes were squinting closed and I had a terrible headache before she ever got her first job!

Some silent movies have new soundtracks that have been re-done and those who work on such projects have my eternal gratitude. So many of these old movies have music that reminds me of a circus--it seems to crescendo with a "ta-da!" every minute or 2 as though the actors on screen completed a big trick on the high wires or survived placing their heads in the jaws of tigers and/or lions. It's exhausting to watch/hear.

The story here bears no resemblance to the sounds of the band playing--and it's a band, not an orchestra. I'm hoping this movie gets a new soundtrack. Since it's well-reviewed, I'd like to see it when it is bearable....it's just too long to have it muted...and tiresome because the action is pretty exaggerated most of the time.

The costumes are ridiculous--a Southern belle with her hoops removed, her skirt shortened, but dressed and styled pre-Civil War? Then made-up like a clown with painted cheeks the day after appearing pretty and suited to 1928? There in no sense to the craziness. A good orchestral soundtrack would help immeasurably.

reply

This movie basically sucked. William Haines was awful, the storyline stunk, every single thing except Marion Davies was bad. If it was not for her I am talking about Walk On The Wild Side and Machete ( my two least favorite films ever). It is hard to imagine that Haines was a leading man, and looking at it from a 2016 perspective he never should have been ( except for Gangster Films, Renee Adore and Clara Bow maybe I just do not get what people liked in that era). He makes Pee Wee Herman and Carrot Top look like John Wayne and Lee Marvin. He goes right to that list of people that if they are in it I am not watching.

reply