MovieChat Forums > The Phantom of the Opera (1925) Discussion > There's always at least 1 dumb moment in...

There's always at least 1 dumb moment in an older movie


"Turn the scorpion to save your lover, or turn the grasshopper to blow the building into pieces." Hmmm, I wonder which one is the obvious one to choose? And she still thinks about turning the grasshopper...huh??

Check out my latest film reviews at: http://moviemuscle.net/

reply

True, but there are usually several dumb moments in many modern films

reply

He's giving her a SAW-like negative option.

Marry me and kill your lover, or reject me and everybody dies.

No matter what option she chooses, somebody dies.

"If you don't know the answer -change the question."

reply

From her point of view, it might be preferable for them all to die quickly in an explosion than to spend the rest of her life in an Elisabeth Fritzl-style existence shut up under the Opera with her kidnapper ~~Igenlode, who thinks Christine gets a bad press Gather round, lads and lasses, gather round...

reply

True. Although in the book she had no way of knowing that the scorpion was going to kill Raoul, only that it would drown the gunpowder and sentence her -in her pov- to a possible rape followed by death. At least blowing everyone up skipped the first part.

So no wonder she thought about just killing them all and having done with it, the girl was already suicidal from months of walking on eggshells to appease this crazy guy she felt sorry for who literally forbade her to fall in love with anyone else but him, if she didn't want a murder on her conscience. In the book, she was tied up when they got there because she'd tried to kill herself ahead of Erik's schedule.

reply