MovieChat Forums > The Iron Horse (1925) Discussion > Not completely realistic

Not completely realistic


The railroad construction was amateurish and not realistic. We never see the organiziation that went into the speed construction records. A few times we are treated to a "musical number" where they uselessly tamp to "Drill ye tarriers, drill", not real work. We never see rails being bolted together.
The story line depends on the fiction of surveying being just ahead of construction.














reply

Regarding your last point - if they'd stuck more closely to the history, where would the human drama be? Ya need that kind of thing to make an exciting film about an engineering challenge. Labor troubles and infrequent Indian attacks and arguments over the route would not have been very entertaining unless personalized.

--If they move, kill 'em!

reply

A Hollywood movie - historically inaccurate? No, really??

-- It don't mean a thing if it ain't got that sting

reply

Not so much because it's Hollywood.

In fact, the majority of all Westerns (novels, film, games) are historically, very inaccurate, even the New Westerns.

The 'Wild' West everybody knows is simply a created mythology.

It's rather pointless to complain about a Western being unrealistic.

reply

As Alfred Hitchcock said, "Drama is life with the dull bits left out." Ford left out the dull bits.

reply

Hitchcock also said "Never let good history get in the way of good story."

Proud member of the Pro-film Anti-digital Society (PFADS).

reply

It is a MOVIE not a documentary.

reply

I kept getting confused when they were talking about the route through the Black Hills. But their route was half a state to the south. Black Hills in So. Dakota, their route was southern Nebraska.

reply