MovieChat Forums > Within Our Gates (1920) Discussion > A great film, is it on DVD?

A great film, is it on DVD?


Why is this not available on DVD? I realize there is a small demand for silent pictures, but some scream for availability for their historical value. Anyone know where I can get this?

reply

I recently viewed this in one of my classes, and the professor informed us that it was available on volume one of "Origins of Film." I just checked Amazon.com for it, and it's part of a 3-disc set that is available from a third-party seller for....$999.88. Luckily I can just check it out from my school's media center, but in your case, I'm not quite sure about your options.

reply

Turner Classic Movies just played it for MLK Day, so at least it's out there in rotation.

I came across it on TCM by accident. What an incredible film. I'm not surprised all American prints were destroyed. We're very lucky the nitrate print survived, hidden for years in fascist Spain, waiting for a brighter day.

reply

I was lucky enough to catch it on tcm, recorded it and put it on dvd.

reply

Yeah, I think that's the only print left. The quality of it is a bit iffy, but at least it survived.

Also, the print had been edited and mucked around with, so it varies slightly from the original...though I guess we'll never know how.

reply

There is a copy on hand at the Library of Congress, and a few other places--Harvard is one, I think. Access to them is limited of course, but if someone could get ahold of one and make a rip, distribution would, to my knowledge, be legal, as the film is in the public domain.

"You whistled wrong. Instead of women, skeletons came."

reply

The surviving print is said to be something like 75% of the original cut. Although the film in its state now is powerful enough as a response to Birth of a Nation.

reply

Just to let everyone know, a Region 2 version of this film is currently being sold on e-bay.

reply

I was able to pick up a $20 copy on Amazon, and grapevinevideo.com is selling it.

reply

I noticed that this film is available in it's entirety on youtube... for free.

reply

It's now available on the DVD set PIONEERS OF AFRICAN-AMERICAN CINEMA, with a number of other Oscar Micheaux movies. You can also currently watch it on Netflix,too.

reply

I got a DVD through inter-library loan. It said Copyright: Video Yesteryear 1983 and Published by: Mad Phat Enterprises 2009. No extras, no explanations just a 1:18 DVD in bad shape especially the last third that kept skipping forward a little bit at a time making the music very annoying. The plot was nearly impossible to understand and characters keep dropping in and out. The intercards didn't help much. This one's for historical viewing only. I sure hope there is a better version out there somewhere.

reply

I also got a copy from a local library - this one released by Grapevine Video (http://www.grapevinevideo.com/oscar_micheaux.html). Quality seems to suggest restoration (of an edited print). It's not pristine considering the age of the film, Grapevine's DVD is a fine presentation.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

TCM is showing it today, July 24, 2016. On the TCM schedule website, there's a link for "buy the DVD": http://shop.tcm.com/within-our-gates-1920/842614102752

reply