MovieChat Forums > Le voyage dans la lune (1902) Discussion > Oh come on. How should you rate Le voyag...

Oh come on. How should you rate Le voyage dans la lune?


Just seen it, and I have no answer.

Did I enjoy it? Was it fun? Was it touching? Was it exciting? Was it...? No, not really, to be honest. It was, for me, just a short story of some people who went to the moon in an unrealistic way.

The colors was flickering, and a bit annoying. Sure, the music was atmospheric and powerful.

So, from 1-10: How should you rate it? I gave it a 10, since I couldn't wrap my head around this issue. I figured a 1 would be a poor choice, and I didn't have a feel for 2-9, so I just gave it a 10.

Is it an enjoying movie? Hell no.

So could you give me your view? And let's see if you could give it a fair point, without being all pretentious about it.


-------Gå på disco rulla hatt, med SunTrip varje natt-------

reply

I'm sure most of the high scores derive from it's historical value. While I do compensate for the era and the intent of the artist, at the end of the day I simply ask myself, "How much was I entertained?", which explains my score, lower than most posters for this particular film.

Damion Crowley
Who knows but that, on the lower frequencies, I speak for you.--R.E.

reply

Actually I was both entertained and amazed by this movie, so I rated it a 9.

Poorly Lived and Poorly Died, Poorly Buried and No One Cried

reply