She should have won!!


I was floored that she didn’t win America’s Next Top Model. She was a million times better than the winner Caridee; Caridee was awful in my opinion. Melrose was robbed!

reply

I couldn't agree more she was the best hands down. I think Tyra was just jealous of Melrose.

reply

I think she was too and they set Caridee up for failure. Caridee did little to no modeling after her win!!!

reply

Indeed Melrose continued modeling and she really had the passion for it.

reply

I remember when Melrose was on the cover of Living North Magazine and she was wearing a bridal gown. She looked beautiful and very high fashion. She also appeared in many runway shows too. I re-watched season 7 on Hulu and Caridee was in the bottom two twice when they went to Spain and she also insulted Nigel Barker. I remember during panel, Tyra claimed that Nigel forgave Caridee for her comments about him but, the look on his face indicated otherwise. In my opinion, I think Tyra forced Nigel to forgive Caridee because she wanted Caridee to win. Also, the commercial they did for Secret deodorant was when Melrose shined; Caridee looked totally drunk in that commercial which caused her to be in the bottom two. Caridee should have been eliminated that day. Her performance was terrible...

reply

Agreed Caridee was abysmal Melrose was on a whole different level.

reply

I remember feeling so shocked when they announced Caridee as the winner. It made absolutely no sense to me.

reply

It reminds me of another model in a different season who was also great but they eliminated her unfairly. Her name was Jenah.

reply

Yes, I believe she was in season 9....

reply

Yeah that's the one! Jenah was the best and it was baffling to see that Saleisha ends up wining that season.

reply

Saleisha was awful! Worst winner ever. All she did after her win were some catalog pictures. She was not high fashion at all and did not look like a model what-so-ever.....

reply

So true and in the season she was floundering and then she got that haircut and then Tyra and company started thinking she was the greatest thing ever.

Her winning was a travesty.

reply

Here is a thread I just did on her:

https://moviechat.org/nm2773575/Sal-Stowers/6065ee76feda3930f82f0ad4/The-worst-America-Next-Top-Model-winner-of-all-time

reply

Oh nice!! I will check out your thread for sure!!!

reply