He should've been Anakin

I agree

Garfield is very good actor while anakin was trash

Oh man, that would've been awesome. Right height, good acting chops, plus it would've been interesting to see him as a bad guy.

He would have been really good, may have been a little young when they cast it in 2000, he was 17 then, Christiansen was only 19 but they probably needed someone over 18.

Exactly. Would have been great, though he still would have had to navigate the horrible writing (especially the love scenes with Natalie Portman).