MovieChat Forums > Alex Pettyfer Discussion > Needs to make better choices

Needs to make better choices


I don't get it, he turns down The Mortal Instruments but does a movie like Beastly. I think this guys a great actor but I think he needs to make better choices as an actor. I think Magic Mike was a fluke because no one really expected that to be a big hit. Hope he is cast in Divergent I think he'd make an excellent Tobias/Four.

reply

This message has been deleted by an administrator

reply

He did Beastly because he wasn't established in the U.S. and Beastly was a low budget film that could take a chance on a little-known actor. I'm glad he turned down The Mortal Instruments.

reply

Personally, I don't get the appeal of Alex Pettyfer. He's an extremely attractive guy but I haven't been blown away by any of his performances. Of course, I don't think he's performed in anything of any real gravitas... so that might explain why. Magic Mike (I haven't seen it) seemed to have been received relatively well by critics, though I don't recall reading a review that said AP was the standout performer. It looks like he got by in that movie and played his part.

It's important to realise that Hollywood and the film industry has a strange way of working. It's a little similar to the way you or I might apply for a job: you need some reasonable credentials on your CV and to deliver a knockout performance in the interview (audition). Alex is still establishing himself in the film industry, so he probably doesn't have the luxury of cherry-picking his projects. Most probably he's taking what he can get... although maybe with the exception that he can say, "This one looks terrible so I don't want to do that. This one has some decent actors/screenwriters attached to it, so I'll have a look at it."

Not sure if any of you are familiar with Logan Lerman, but he recently gave some really good insight into a lengthy interview. I feel that I can comfortably say that Lerman is more established than Pettyfer in the US. He's been acting there for quite some time now, and been in a few (critically) well-received projects. Still, he's still auditioning with the rest of them... it makes sense that Pettyfer would be on a level (if not lower) playing field.

You can watch the interview here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EOpEA1ozf3Q

All that aside, I've gotta admit: I'm surprised he turned down TMI. Maybe he thought he was already apart of a potentially large franchise - I Am Number Four - and wanted to steer clear of the fantasy-world realm? Who knows? I definitely think he LOOKS the part of Jace, but I couldn't say the same for his acting chops. Honestly, I think if they had cast himself/Lily Collins in the lead role, the film would have tanked (on a critic level) - no doubt fans would have still rallied to watch them all. Not sure if it's wishful thinking but I do believe JCB might be able to bring more to the role.

reply

Excellent response, and he could get some exposure, hone his craft and not have to carry a whole film

reply

Make better choices? Well - go the The Butler.

reply

Okay?!!! :), he did the thing!!!

reply

Saw I am number four. Saw Magic mike. Saw number four again when it hit netflix and suddenly remembered the guy from Magic mike. I think he does excellent work in both. Especially in magic mike. He's supposed to be the protagonist. The inexperienced guy whe relate to...In my opinion. Nailed it. But at the same time I agree with the people calling for him to get a part in which he plays another part of the plot. Let's see what the kid's made off! :D

reply

Magic Mike and The Butler are not bad choices. Gtfo! They were both really, really well liked by critics. Magic Mike was a huge BO hit too, and so is The Butler now.
He's doing a good job :).

reply