MovieChat Forums > Lilly Wachowski Discussion > He's a biological male.

He's a biological male.


Attaching female parts, injecting hormones and female pronouns do not make a woman. This is not my opinion, it's biology.

What did you expect to be under here?

reply

He's a man. Woman is who ever born woman. This is a male man who has troubles and got a costume.

Please do not ruin humanity.

reply

Most trans females don't have their penis and balls snipped. Just hormones for boobs. Superficially "female".

reply

With zero hope of ever "passing".

Really, why bother if you're not going to come out looking... at least okay?

reply

It's true, DNA doesn't lie. Nothing this person does is gonna make him into something he's not. And he's not fooling anyone with the dress-up routine.

reply

I feel like this issue is just a fad and there's going to be a lot of buyer's remorse in the future.

reply

[deleted]

You know what's funny, is that it's the people from the Right Wing side of the spectrum who have brought transgenders, gender-fluidity and "Wokeness" to the forefront NOT the actual trannies or SJW/Woke culture.

reply

I’ve always really wanted to be a great white shark, deep down in my soul, so I will now spend the rest of my days flopping around on the floor with a plastic dorsal fin on my back, and if anyone refers to me as a human you’re a disgusting hate filled bigot, and whatever “-ist” word works in this situation, and how dare you question my mental health!!! 🤣

reply

What if he is biologically a male but his brain shows that he is wired like a female? Male and female brains often do work differently. Some gay men seem to have a female brain due to their likes, dislikes and emotional rections, but at the same time, love having a man's body (perhaps because they get to feel their own male bits, a win-win for them.)

In the case of trans-gender, sometimes their brains will show that they were 'born in the wrong body'. But when people like him change later in life, I wonder, does the brain start to rewire itself to appear female as well? Such a weird thing.

Gender fluidity occurs in nature too. I remember hearing about fish that change gender if a female is needed. That's pretty full on.

reply

There is no way to show faulty brain-wiring, no more than with other conditions. All we have is the so-called transgender's word on it. That is an emotional concept, not a physical/physiological one. (and people are not fish, or other organisms, for example, that eat/defecate from the same opening).

reply

I think it may be a mental illness for some but for others, the wrong gendered brain in the wrong body.

I don't agree with transitioning children though to avoid puberty. Sickening.

reply

Yeah, that's my theory. If there's something in the human brain that says "I am male" or "I am female", then that little neural cue is going to go wrong in a few people. But it's also obvious that a lot of transgender people aren't like that, they have other things going on inside.

The thing is, there's no known biological basis for transgenderism. If you're a man with a dick and balls and XY chromosones and believe you're a woman or were meant to be a woman, you aren't a woman, you're a man with gender dysphoria. Now the best way to deal with gender dysphoria may indeed to go for the medical transition and live the life you want to live, and I see nothing wrong with that - unless you start denying scientific realities. Because believing you are something doesn't make you that thing - if I believe I'm a hummingbird I don't develop the ability to fly, if I believe I'm 19 and beautiful, it doesn't make other people want to nail me. So there's really a limit to how much a person can do to change their life to match their self-image.

As for people like Lily... oy. What's going to become of someone who wants to be a pretty girl, and will never look like anything but an older man in a dress. Real life can't possibly match their expectations.

reply

We cannot genetically test or do a CT Scan for this, though. (you cannot do one for a concussion or that disease that football payers get from constant head trauma, though there other symptoms present). With other disorders or conditions, there are tangible symptoms.

But, I agree, children should not remotely be thinking about "transitioning", and to subject a child to the notion is abusive. People think they are being progressive, when it's only self-defeating

reply

I agree and those self-described progressives are no different than the those right wing yahoos who live in the boondocks who shield their children from interacting with the outside world. I actually have a cousin who is encouraging her son to transition and he's only 7 fucking years old. It's amazing how entitled she feels to let her son "think freely" when in reality she's shielding him from it.

reply

Geez. The thing to do is report her to Social Services and report that she's doing such. Even if she denies it, it's better than nothing. (social services may not think it qualifies for negligence either, I dont' know). I highly doubt any physician would condone this,

reply

She can't take him to get "fixed" but she does bullshit like doing cross-dressing events. It also doesn't help that she has two girlfriends who are also mothers and doing the same shit with their kids.

I'm staying out of it as the father who is seeking divorce is also fighting for custody. He has the financial upper hand as he's the bread winner and she's been disability (mental reasons) and can't work so he can actually use that in the court to fight for custody.

reply

For custody, I imagine it would depend on the nature of her mental-illness/ ability to function. But if she proudly admits in court that she's leaning the child towards gender-change/ cross-dressing, that would be enough

reply