MovieChat Forums > Toby Stephens Discussion > How has this man not been nominated for ...

How has this man not been nominated for an Emmy for Black Sails?


His performance, particularly in Season 2, has been entirely fantastic. His range of character and emotion, from quiet heroism to seething brute, from terrible anger to composed longing and despair; it's been completely mesmerizing at times. Whilst the quality of writing and acting certainly dips in and out on the show, Stephans carries every scene he is in with a gravity and intensity that I've rarely seen on TV. It is surely nomination worthy, at least.

I don't mean to fawn. Just thought I would share how impressed I've been with his acting in Black Sails. It would be interesting to hear some other opinions.

reply

I'd never seen him before (or even heard of him, for that matter) and became an instant fan. He's phenomenal. I'm devastated this is the last season....

I WILL NEVER GIVE UP!

reply

I too first noticed Toby Stephens in 'Black Sails' and was quite blown away by his portrayal of Captain Flint. IMO he is absolutely fantastic, the role just made for him. Many fans of the show were also amazed and disappointed that he was not nominated for an Emmy this year. Maybe 'Sails' was not as high profile as others like 'Game of Thrones' or 'Mr Robot' for instance, who knows?

I have now seen most of Toby's work and agree that he is a phenomenal acting talent. It seems he has been a respected stage performer for most of his career and has reportedly turned down Hollywood many times and much prefers the theater, although his resume does also include some quality British TV productions and the occasional movie. Before 'Black Sails' he was probably best known as a Bond villain in 'Die Another Day' and as Rochester in a wonderful 2006 BBC production of 'Jane Eyre'. Toby also comes from acting royalty, his father being Sir Robert Stephens, a knight of the London stage, and his mother Dame Maggie Smith.

This is an article about the biggest Emmy snubs this year and 'Black Sails' is mentioned.

https://www.inverse.com/article/18280-the-biggest-emmy-snubs-of-2016-include-the-leftovers-penny-dreadful-black-sails

I particularly like this bit

'Starz’s Black Sails might have flown under award radars in its first season, but three seasons deep, Toby Stephens’s nuanced performance as the complicated Captain Flint cannot be ignored. His every facial expression conveys at least five different emotions at once; his every movement telegraphing seething rage beneath his cold exterior. Toby Stephens as Flint is an actor-character match that’s akin to Bryan Cranston as Walter White. When he breaks down in tears in the third episode and gives an earth shattering monologue in the fifth episode, both moments act circles around anything else on this year’s TV.'





reply

Those of us who have followed Toby's career for years, know what a great actor he is. 




If there aren't any skeletons in a man's closet, there's probably a Bertha in his attic.

reply

Because the Emmys are a joke. It is nothing but a popularity contest. The actor that is "trending" the most wins. Hence why Emilia Clarke keeps winning it, while the (way) better actors on GoT doesn't even get nominated. If the Emmys had been about acting skills Toby, and others would be nominated for sure. Instead we get Clarke and Lady Gaga winning them.

reply