Oscar nom, really?


why - she didn't make the role that much more amazing, she's playing something that might not be too hard to portray for her as a black woman raised in the South - and frankly it was a caricature, and the help was more movie of the week than a true theatrical quality release.

The Oscars are too politically correct sometimes, and have to nominate someone just to include everybody regardless of quality.

Look at Halle Berry - which was a mistake in giving (she didn't earn that oscar, please...) the best actress award. What a joke! and she hasn't done jack since, and she didn't do that much before. What PC garbage.

There are better more deserving best supporting actress and I didn't think Melissa Mcarthy deserved it either - and I loved Bridesmaids and her performance in it, but it's a comedy, and she's a comedian, and it wasn't like it was a hard performance for McCarthy either.

Jonah Hill did an excellent job as a supporting actor if you want to understand what I consider a worthy nomination.

Shailene Woodley (even though I didn't think The Descendants was that great) did a great performance as well. Actually, if anybody from The Help got a nom - and it's a stretch for both of them for the specific roles - Viola (who I think is an excellent actress, but not for this role though she did a decent job) and Jessica (which I didn't think she deserved it as much as for her other roles in other movies for the year).

I even think Gadboure Sideby did a magnificent job in Precious, so didn't start the typical vitriol for honesty.

reply

This message has been deleted by the poster

reply

she's playing something that might not be too hard to portray for her as a black woman raised in the South

And that fat chick from Braidsmaids didnt portray a character raised as a white woman? How insulting and this is why I hope Octavia doesn't win because this is how all black women are seen by white people.

reply

Dissagree. She was splendid and stoled the show. I hope she wins, she deserves it.

reply

I like Octavia's performance but it wasn't an amazing performance to me. She was good but the character didn't seem that hard to portray; not because she is a black woman. The character just jumps from angry to happy. Jessica stole the show for me. She was heart wrenching to watch, the way she tried to please the people that hated her and her own husband. That was beautiful.

-----
Get prizes with google searches.
http://www.swagbucks.com/refer/orca

reply

i thought she was better as the pet psychic in Dinner for Schmucks or maybe I'm just tired of hearing about her


who cares

reply

did you really just belittle McCarthy because of comedy?

newsflash comedy is far harder to do than drama

anyone can make you feel depressed or sad for someone

it takes talent to make you legitimately laugh

reply

Bridesmaids was waaaay overrated. I laughed about two times. I guess I just didn't find the gross humor funny

reply

if you read the book, the author states that Minny Jackson, was written based on Octavia's personaility. So she did technically portrayed herself. I think she was amazing and she deserves to win, and really it is an honour to get an oscar for just being yourself. that means you're a pretty good person, not just an actor. hahahaha

reply