MovieChat Forums > Elliot Page Discussion > She's a trans-trender

She's a trans-trender

posted 3 years ago by OvertonPendulum (4026)
10 replies | jump to latest

- A transgender is someone who underwent sex change procedure because he or she has gender dysphoria.
- A transtrender is someone who doesn't have gender dysphoria, feels totally comfortable in their own body and is identifying as the opposite sex merely because there is a trend in society to do so.

She is factually a transtrender. This isn't even a matter of opinion. If she lived in a society where there is no popular trend to identify as transgender, she would have been totally comfortable identifying as a female like she has been for 33 years of her life.

And please don't come at me with "it's a he, not a she" bullshit. This isn't a civil rights issue, she isn't a victim of nature like people with gender dysphoria. She's just a confused girl who's a victim of a crazy society. She's could be also seeking attention, like it has been become popular with celebrities.

[–] rateater (9206) 3 years ago

robots in disguise

[–] drrclavan (667) 3 years ago

No, SHE is a FREAK with MENTAL problems. There is NOTHING wrong with her body, in fact I would have loved to have a go at her body pre-nonsense.

There is NO SUCH THING as a transgender. Sure, surgery can make you LOOK like someone from the opposite sex but you'll never be one. You CAN NOT fool chromosomes! Women with a dick glued on can't suddenly parallel park cars and men with their willy cut off don't suddenly enjoy discussing the colour of the new curtains.

These sick people have a MENTAL problem, NOT a physical one.

Ellen Page is a deeeeeply troubled girl, she needs to see a psychiatrist. We need to STOP applauding people with mental illnesses as if they're doing something fantastic, they are NOT.

In the future people will look back on this time and condemn this whole 'transgender'-nonsense like we do the burning of witches. And rightfully so.

[–] Lord Rake (3757) 3 years ago

"We need to STOP applauding people with mental illnesses as if they're doing something fantastic, they are NOT."

Well you're going to be a real party pooper at the special olympics.

[–] drrclavan (667) 3 years ago

I don't care about special olympics, normal olympics or any sport for that matter (except for female tennis, for obvious reasons).

[–] Jinx (3040) 3 years ago

A board certified psychiatrist would tell you that being transgender is not a mental illness so it's obvious that you don't have a clue what you are talking about.

[–] drrclavan (667) 3 years ago

No he wouldn't. Look, it really is very simple, even you can understand. I'll explain.

Look at the body of Ellen Page (as we know it, say from 5 years ago). Is there ANYTHING wrong with that body? Does the body maybe have 3 arms? Or is it missing a leg? Is it an ugly body? Is there anything out of the ordinary with that body?

Your answer should be a resounding NO. There is absolutely NOTHING wrong with the body. It's a perfectly fine body and if it were up to me I would have had a lot of fun with that body.

So, we've established there is nothing wrong with the body.

Ellen Page (or any other mental nutcase) claiming they were born in 'the wrong body' are wrong from the onset. There is nothing wrong with the body. Well, if there's nothing wrong with the body yet they aren't happy, what else could it be that's malfunctioning? Indeed! THEIR BRAIN!

Schizos one moment think they're Bob and the next moment they're Jack and then Bert, followed by Eugene. They too have a MENTAL problem.

People that hear voices in their head telling them to KILL KILL KILL, have a MENTAL problem.

People that are suicidal have a MENTAL problem.

People who have borderline have a MENTAL problem.

But you think that when someone says "Hey! Hold on! I have a penis dangling between by legs, but... but... BUT I AM A WOMAN!?" that that is not a mental problem?

They are ALL absolute mental NUTCASES.

I feel that I am Brad Pitt and as such I want like to look like Brad Pitt, but I don't. Am I born in the wrong body? Should I undergo operation after operation to look like Brad Pitt? Or should I SIMPLY ACCEPT that I do NOT look like Brad Pitt, and never will, and move on with my life, instead of whining everywhere that I was born in the wrong body? I think even you would agree that I would have a mental problem, stop wanting to look like Brad Pitt and move on.

Well, guess what. Same with Ellen Page and the other freaks with MENTAL problems.

[–] OvertonPendulum (4026) 3 years ago

I mean I'm on your side here, but think this is a losing strategy. Weather or not it's a mental illness is irrelevant in actuality. Why? Because we do not (yet) have the technology to change someone's brain. We do however have the technology to change the body.

There will always be a lot of people who feel sorry for people with gender dysphoria. After all, they were crewed by nature by giving them this condition. The problem aren't people with gender dysphoria. They have existed for a long time and have been transitioning. The problem currently is the new modern craze that even people without gender dyphoria are trans. People who feel totally comfortable in their bodies. People who have been totally happy identifying as the sex they were born in for most of their life until suddenly now (when there is a popular tendency to identify as trans) they claim to be transgenders. This is crazy. If you feel comfortable in your own body, you are not trans. I see no evidence that their desire to identify as trans isn't 100% generated by society and identity politics.

[–] Kowalski (57351) 3 years ago

GOOD CALL...ALL HE NEEDS IS A GOOD HARD DICKING...AND THE CLOUDS WILL LIFT ON HER CONFUSION...SHE WILL BE FIXED...GET RIGHT ON THAT BRO.

[–] AzureSeb (465) 3 years ago

She can call herself whatever she wants, but she was born a female and will die one. Fact.

[–] AmeriGirl26 (12253) 3 years ago

Oh trust me, I've seen this trick before, when an actor's career is falling apart or going downhill. They'll do something crazy and spontaneous to get people's attention in a last-ditch effort to save their dying career, though it doesn't always work.

In this case, Ellen identified as gay, and since it's now more fashionable to be a tranny in Hollywood instead, she decided to up her game to save her pitiful career. Chances are, she'll change back to her usual self when the hype dies down, and then claim that she's non-binary or something; but it'll be ages after nobody cares about her anymore, and nobody notices when she posts that she was faking it.

I remember when Raven Simone came out of the closet. She was extremely subtle about it, and had already become yesterday's news by the time fake gay marriage was made "legal," and then she just casually says on her social media "Great, now I can get married!" which is the only indication she ever gave of being gay. But by then, everyone who had watched her on Disney Channel in the early 2000s had mostly forgotten about her, and it was as if she'd disappeared off the face of the planet.

There's also that issue with Kevin Spacey, where he came out when his career was in jeopardy after kids he'd sexually abused came forward for revenge against him. Letting everyone know he was gay did not save him, and he still lost his job on "House of Cards."