Murder of a Cat
http://collider.com/synopses-2012-lionsgate-films-the-evil-dead-remake -spike-lee-old-boy/123549/
Murder of a Cat
Cast: Jay Baruchel, Alison Pill, Dianne Wiest, Rob Lowe, JK Simmons
Director: Gillian Greene Raimi
Writers: Christian Magalhaes, Robert Snow
Synopsis:
A hapless 28-year-old eccentric vows justice when he finds his beloved cat shot dead with a crossbow arrow. After some sleuthing, he is shocked to discover that his cat was living a double life with a mysterious young woman. Forced into an awkward partnership, the two cat owners must embark on an epic suburban murder mystery that leads them to a conspiracy far greater than they ever imagined.
Didn't know about the existence of this movie at all, but it definitely sounds like a movie Jay would be in. The rest of the cast is great too.