MovieChat Forums > Katie Holmes Discussion > Best Rachel Dawes HANDS DOWN!

Best Rachel Dawes HANDS DOWN!


Gyllenhaal was to hollow there was no emotion in her performance in TDK while Holmes was excellent as Rachel she played the character with full of life. You cared for her while with Gyllenhaal was really hollow so it was impossible to be sad when Rachel died when Gyllenhaal was her.

If Holmes had been Rachel in TDK you would actually feel sad like Bruce did when she died



CW network sucks ass!

reply

Couldn't agree more!

reply

I smell a couple SOB's,aren't you????

reply

I do concur also Maggie Gyllenhaal is ugly as hell and no where as attractive as Katie is. They could have casted at least another hottie to replace Katie

reply

I can't believe Maggie is only a year older. She seemed like she was in her fourties.

She made me hate Rachel.I feel that if Katie had done TDK, you could at least sympathize with her for acting the way she did and choosing Harvey. Plus Katie is more likeable. She didn't even have chemistry with Bale, she seemed like a nagging older sister.

I bet Katie regrets it now. She could have been part of an awesome franchise and it could have helped her career.

I'm Bane yes, that's my name. When you hear the name Bane, I guarantee the pain. I’m coming after you, Bruce Wayne. I’m stronger, smarter, clinically insane.

This love will be your downfall

reply

Still stuck in 1999,eh Starry????

reply

Totally agree

reply

Lol. No, I didn't watch Dawson's Creek.

I'm Bane yes, that's my name.

reply

Yeah,right!!!

reply