MovieChat Forums > Peter Jackson Discussion > Harvey Weinstein told Peter Jackson not ...

Harvey Weinstein told Peter Jackson not to hire Mira Sorvino or Ashley Judd for "Lord of the Rings"


Although I don't know why he'd consider either of them in the first place, there are only three decent female roles in LOTR and Judd and Sorvino weren't suitable for any of them.

https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/dec/15/peter-jackson-harvey-weinstein-ashley-judd-mira-sorvino

Which provides a partial answer to a big unanswered question about Weinstein and the sexual harassment scandal - if an actress turned down his advances, did he damage their careers?

Which is a surprisingly difficult question to answer, because an actor never really knows why their career ups and downs happen. If they get no offers is it because they aren't good enough, or because they have enemies working behind the scenes, or some other factor? So since an actor would never be sure if Weinstein was trying to ruin them, and Weinstein would never admit it if he did, we'll never really know if all these gals were right to be afraid of refusing his advances.

Unless, of course, other industry bigwigs come out and admit that they were pressured or influenced to blacklist actresses who wouldn't play ball with Harvey. I suppose this is as much proof as we're ever going to get.

reply

I expect a future lawsuit if a second person comes forth to corroborate this.

reply

The thing is, Sorvino at least has been rumored to be difficult, according to other sources.

So if I'm correct and Weinstein chose to ruin Sorvino's career by using a certain amount of truth in his smear campaign, he's REALLY smart. I'd he'd called everyone in Hollywood and said "Do me a favor and give the job to someone else" then he'd owe far too many favors. If he called everyone and said "Hire her and I'm your enemy for life", he'd make too many enemies. But if he "warned" everyone that she was worse than they thought and too much trouble to consider working with, he both cost her work and appeared to be the guy who was doing a favor to the various directors and casting people!

And if I'm right and she was at least somewhat difficult to work with, then she can't even sue him. Not as long as he can show she was a pain on set, and he knew about it.

reply

I have never heard of Sorvino being difficult, but Judd I have definitely heard horror stories about her.

reply

For all I know, Weinstein started the rumors I heard, back when she was a thing.

Ashley Judd... probably not so much, she is known to be a pain.

reply