If Jim had a cameo in the TV show Frequency

Obviously it's too late for that but if he had had a cameo which do you think is better

scenario 1 Raimy does something good and everyone at the police department are congratulating her and Jim has a cameo as a fellow officer who gives her as a hi) high five or shakes her hand not as a passing of the hat or anything like that but more like acknowledging Peyton List is playing his character.

scenario 2 She does something bad and everyone at the police department is mad at her and Jim has a cameo as a fellow officer who walks past and says sarcastically "nice job" or something like that.